Reds Additions

Andy Quote:

Reds Needs from POST & EXP
EXP-Maybe a 2b choice that falls somewhere between Morgan and Oester.

This should get mileage. My Reds choice.
2011 Brandon Phillips
http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/906/2011/1/2011

As a big Reds fan an obscure addition would be Kevin Mitchell 1994. He was a monster that season and would be a fun addition.

2003 Jose Guillen

He would be an impact! but not even one full season with the Reds. Put him on the list but I have him ranked low for now.

Here's what I'm thinking from the Reds...
1. Joey Votto 2010
2. Noodles Hahn 1902
3. Brandon Phillips 2011
4. Adam Dunn 2004
5. Cy Seymour 1905
6. Ted Abernathy 1967
7. Reggie Sanders 1995
8. Rob Murphy 1986
9. Danny Jackson 1988
10. Aroldis Chapman 2012
11. Loe Cardenas 1965

Probably nominate our top 6...thoughts before I do?

No Bobby Tolan?

So after reading up on Tolan I have him at 12+ so didn't list him. Happy to take arguments to include him...

So after reading up on Tolan I have him at 12+ so didn't list him. Happy to take arguments to include him...

He was just a favorite from my youth. Hard to make a statistical arguement, but I'd vote him over the more recent players who's careers aren't over yet

I'll throw this in. Better balanced hitter with better stealing than Geronimo, and Davis is too much money for a guy that mainly crushes lefties

So after reading up on Tolan I have him at 12+ so didn't list him. Happy to take arguments to include him...

He was just a favorite from my youth. Hard to make a statistical arguement, but I'd vote him over the more recent players who's careers aren't over yet

I'll throw this in. Better balanced hitter with better stealing than Geronimo, and Davis is too much money for a guy that mainly crushes lefties

If you really dig him I'm happy to bump him ahead of Cy Seymour who has a card already.

So after reading up on Tolan I have him at 12+ so didn't list him. Happy to take arguments to include him...

He was just a favorite from my youth. Hard to make a statistical arguement, but I'd vote him over the more recent players who's careers aren't over yet

I'll throw this in. Better balanced hitter with better stealing than Geronimo, and Davis is too much money for a guy that mainly crushes lefties

If you really dig him I'm happy to bump him ahead of Cy Seymour who has a card already.

I don't know how others feel, but if I only had 5 votes and Tolan was on the ballot, he'd get one of them

Rejiggered from the Reds...
1. Joey Votto 2010
2. Noodles Hahn 1902
3. Bobby Tolan 1970
4. Brandon Phillips 2011
5. Adam Dunn 2004
6. Cy Seymour 1905
7. Ted Abernathy 1967
8. Reggie Sanders 1995
9. Rob Murphy 1986
10. Danny Jackson 1988
11. Aroldis Chapman 2012
12. Loe Cardenas 1965

Thoughts to the contrary?