ATG Card ADD POLL FOR FINAL 19

Discussion for new cards to add; moderated by Rosie2167

Moderator: BC15NY

Vote for 19 to be included with the 31 = 50

Poll ended at Thu Jul 21, 2016 10:42 pm

Anderson Garrett 2003 LF ANG .885 OPS, 17 yrs no card
40
3%
Arrieta Jake 2015 SP EXP/CHC .86 whip/CY
41
3%
Balfour Grant 2008 RP TB .89 whip
29
2%
Bichette Dante 1995 OF COL 340/364/620/1084
35
3%
Bottomley Jim 1928 1B STL 402 OBP 1030 OPS, BC
40
3%
Braun Ryan 2011 LF MIL MVP/332/397/597/994
31
3%
Brouthers Dan 1886 1B DB/DET 370/445/581/1026
35
3%
Buckner Bill 1980 1B CHC BRC/batchamp/324/353/457/810
40
3%
Colavito Rocky 1958 RF 1B CLV 41 HR, 405 OBP 1024 OPS CLV Card
38
3%
Dotel Octavio 2002 RP HOU .87 whip
29
2%
Farrell Turk 1963 SP HOU .96 whip, SP Card
30
2%
Finley Steve 1996 CF SDP 30HR, 885 OPS
40
3%
Fothergill Bob 'Fats' 1927 LF DET 359 Ave, 413 OBP, 929 OPS
36
3%
Hunt Ron 1971 2B EXPOS/NAT New Franch 279/402/358/759
31
3%
Johnson Randy 1995 SP SEA CY, ERA Leader 2.48, 1.05 whip, fixes no SEA card
33
3%
Joost Eddie 1949 SS A's BRC 429 OBP 883 OPS
40
3%
Kiner Ralph 1951 LF 1B PostWar/PIT 42HR/309/452/627/1079
36
3%
Law Vern 1965 SP PIT BC/.99 whip 2.15 ERA
27
2%
Leiter Al 1998 SP NYM 1.15 whip, 19 yr career no card
42
3%
Lemon Chet 1979 CF CHW 887 OPS New Franch
30
2%
Lidge Brad 2004 RP EXP/HOU .91whip
32
3%
McDowell Sam 1965 SP PostWar/CLV 1.13 whip
33
3%
McGriff Fred 1992 1B SDP 35HR, 950 OPS
36
3%
Mussina Mike 1995 SP BAL 1.06 whip, other card is NYY
33
3%
Nevin Phil 2001 3B SDP 41HR/306/388/588/976
38
3%
Oswalt Roy 2006 SP HOU 1.16 whip BRC
26
2%
Peavy Jake 2007 SP SDP CY, 1.06
33
3%
Putz JJ 2007 RP SEA .69 whip
32
3%
Runnels Pete 1958 1B 2B RSX MBRC, 416 OBP, 854 OPS
34
3%
Sale Chris 2014 SP CHW .96 whip
43
4%
Stennett Rennie 1977 2B PIT MBRC/D-1,336/376/430/806
48
4%
Tannehill Jesse 1902 SP DB/PIT .98 whip 1.95 ERA
33
3%
Utley Chase 2008 2B PHI BD 2e14, 33HR, 380 OBP, 915 OPS
41
3%
Vernon Mickey 1946 1B WSH/MIN BRC, Bat champ 353 Ave, 403 OBP 910 OPS
41
3%
 
Total votes : 1206

  • Author
  • Message
Offline

Rosie2167

  • Posts: 1975
  • Joined: Mon Dec 23, 2013 5:55 pm

ATG Card ADD POLL FOR FINAL 19

PostMon Jul 18, 2016 10:42 pm

Please pick 19 players you'd like to see added to ATG. This is the last poll for this add and these top 19 will be added to the previously voted in 31.
-A tie for 19 will be broken by comparing votes from round 1. If another Tie Breaker is needed we will add the player with the least amount of cards currently in ATG. If another Tie Breaker is needed we will refer to the Franchise or ERA ranking of that player. I sure hope that covers it.

Google spreadsheet of all players:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... sp=sharing

Also you can refer to the Nominations string to see more detail on the players posted by the Ambassadors.

I cut and paste the information from the master spreadsheet so apologies for the messiness, I was just trying to help expedite the voting process. Most of what you'll see next the players name is recognizable but here's the key...

First Name, Last Name, Year, Position, Franchise or ERA nominated by, Current Cards in ATG/Franchise or ERA Rank, my notes.

In those notes are a few acronyms:
BC = Better Card than whats in the current set
BRC = Better Representative Card than whats in the current set
MBRC = Much Better Representative Card than whats in the current set
A few Defensive ratings listed
I think everything else is pretty straightforward.

VOTE!
Offline

Rosie2167

  • Posts: 1975
  • Joined: Mon Dec 23, 2013 5:55 pm

Re: ATG Card ADD POLL FOR FINAL 19

PostTue Jul 19, 2016 12:02 pm

In my haste to get this poll out I didn't cut and paste from the spreadsheet where I edited the format to include CURRENT CARDS IN ATG / FRANCHISE OR ERA RANK. Same exact players just missing that info. Those details are below for your added review.

Arrieta Jake 2015 SP EXP/CHC 0/1 .86 whip/CY
Brouthers Dan 1886 1B DB/DET 1/1 370/445/581/1026
Colavito Rocky 1958 RF 1B CLV 2/1 41 HR, 405 OBP 1024 OPS CLV Card
Kiner Ralph 1951 LF 1B PostWar/PIT 2/5 42HR/309/452/627/1079
Lidge Brad 2004 RP EXP/HOU 0/4 .91whip
McGriff Fred 1992 1B SDP 1/3 35HR, 950 OPS
Mussina Mike 1995 SP BAL 1/1 1.06 whip, other card is NYY
Peavy Jake 2007 SP SDP 0/1 CY, 1.06
Putz JJ 2007 RP SEA 0/1 .69 whip
Buckner Bill 1980 1B CHC 1/1 BRC/batchamp/324/353/457/810
McDowell Sam 1965 SP PostWar/CLV 2/1 1.13 whip
Vernon Mickey 1946 1B WSH/MIN 1/1 BRC, Bat champ 353 Ave, 403 OBP 910 OPS
Bichette Dante 1995 OF COL 0/4 340/364/620/1084
Bottomley Jim 1928 1B STL 1/3 402 OBP 1030 OPS, BC
Fothergill Bob 'Fats' 1927 LF DET 0/4 359 Ave, 413 OBP, 929 OPS
Joost Eddie 1949 SS A's 2/5 BRC 429 OBP 883 OPS
Leiter Al 1998 SP NYM 0/4 1.15 whip, 19 yr career no card
Sale Chris 2014 SP CHW 0/4 .96 whip
Utley Chase 2008 2B PHI 1/2 BD 2e14, 33HR, 380 OBP, 915 OPS
Anderson Garrett 2003 LF ANG 0/2 .885 OPS, 17 yrs no card
Braun Ryan 2011 LF MIL 0/2 MVP/332/397/597/994
Farrell Turk 1963 SP HOU 1/3 .96 whip, SP Card
Hunt Ron 1971 2B EXPOS/NAT 1/5 New Franch 279/402/358/759
Johnson Randy 1995 SP SEA 3/2 CY, ERA Leader 2.48, 1.05 whip, fixes no SEA card
Balfour Grant 2008 RP TB 0/4 .89 whip
Dotel Octavio 2002 RP HOU 0/4 .87 whip
Law Vern 1965 SP PIT 2/2 BC/.99 whip 2.15 ERA
Lemon Chet 1979 CF CHW 2/5 887 OPS New Franch
Nevin Phil 2001 3B SDP 0/4 41HR/306/388/588/976
Oswalt Roy 2006 SP HOU 1/2 1.16 whip BRC
Runnels Pete 1958 1B 2B RSX 1/2 MBRC, 416 OBP, 854 OPS
Stennett Rennie 1977 2B PIT 1/4 MBRC/D-1,336/376/430/806
Tannehill Jesse 1902 SP DB/PIT 1/9 .98 whip 1.95 ERA
Finley Steve 1996 CF SDP 0/2 30HR, 885 OPS
Offline

satyre

  • Posts: 1
  • Joined: Thu Jan 10, 2013 12:40 am

Re: ATG Card ADD POLL FOR FINAL 19

PostFri Jul 29, 2016 8:35 pm

I know the poll ended (I'm typically late), but I hope that at least Arrieta, Kiner, Putz and Sale were selected.
Offline

Radagast Brown

  • Posts: 2946
  • Joined: Sun Mar 17, 2013 7:25 pm

Re: ATG Card ADD POLL FOR FINAL 19

PostSat Jul 30, 2016 3:49 am

I voted for Kiner. He played post war and he kicked butt.
Offline

nels52

  • Posts: 352
  • Joined: Thu Aug 23, 2012 3:50 pm

Re: ATG Card ADD POLL FOR FINAL 19

PostSat Jul 30, 2016 9:26 pm

Sale was my big hope. Very happy see that hopefully diabolically priced 5man card make the cut.

Seems we got ALOT of cards that could make big waves?

Prices for Trout/Cabrera/Harper?

Return to --- ATG Card Discussions

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests