Giants Additions

Bonds' 2002 and 2004 seasons are unlike any others in baseball history. Surely they deserve inclusion as well.

Morning Druid
The cards suggested for Tiernan, Davis and Bonds are definitely better than anyone on the current list. For me its the pre 1900 bias I have and for Bonds, the 3 cards already in. But if we're talking impact cards the guys you're suggesting would get more play than Lockman, outside of an ERA league.

If you feel strongly about the above guys I'm happy to defer the priority list to you. How would you rank the top 5 hitters?

Also what's your opinion on the pitchers list?

Tiernan
Bonds
Davis
Lockman

Should keep us busy for a year.

Pitchers

Schmidt
Bumgarner
Cain

Schmidt is on the list already due to his rank during 16.1, Bumgarner is also a good call...which year would you suggest? 2013 or 2015?

Either one. The 2013 has the better hits per inning ratio but WHIP and ERA+ suggest the 2015 card.

However, looking at the cards I prefer 2013.

2015 would get my vote. But I bow to my betters.....

Bill

Bonds and Bumgarner for me.

Buck Ewing '89 C

Promoting:

SP - Bumgarner 2013 (based on $$ value of 2013 set card)
OF - Mike Tiernan 1896

let's keep the priority list alive, I'll rerank here soon.

tks
Rosie

Please include me as a Giants ambassador.

Bill