Some good options. Andy suggested the Phillies trade their batter spot to the Marlins for their pitcher spot. Fine by me and would allow both Bedrosian 1987 CY year and Cole Hamels, 2008 to get on the list.
1999 Mike Lieberthal .300 31 96 .363 .551 .914. Gold glove at catcher Lieberthal was a catcher for the Phillies from 1994-2006 and caught more than 100 games 7 times during that span and would probably have caught far more if not limited by injuries. Not only could he hit, but he was an excellent defensive catcher.