CLOSED - Batters Poll for ATG Card Add 16.2

Discussion for new cards to add; moderated by Rosie2167

Moderator: BC15NY

Pick 10 Batters

Poll ended at Thu Nov 10, 2016 3:34 pm

Hunt Ron 1971 EXP/NAT 2B 1 12 BC 402OBP MON card
37
3%
Braun Ryan 2011 MIL LF 0 10 994OPS 33HR 1MVP
34
3%
Tolan Bobby 1970 CIN CF 0 15 316/384/475/860 57SB 16MVP
41
3%
Lee Derrek 2003 FLA 1B 0 15 888OPS 33HR 1e5 27MVP
20
2%
Castilla Vinny 1998 COL 3B 0 16 951OPS 46HR 11MVP
39
3%
Holiday Matt 2007 COL LF 0 13 1012OPS 36HR 2MVP
36
3%
Cravath Gavvy 1913 PHI OF 2 11 BC 974OPS 19HR 2MVP
36
3%
Flick Elmer 1900 PHI OF 2 13 MBC 986OPS 110RBI LL 367BA
30
2%
Goldschmidt Paul 2015 AZ 1B 0 6 1005OPS 33HR 2MVP
39
3%
Berkman Lance 2006 HOU OF 1B 1 15 1041OPS 45HR 3MVP
39
3%
Beltran Carlos 2003 KCR OF 1 18 911OPS 26HR 9MVP No KC Card
24
2%
Williams Cy 1924 PHI CF 1 19 MMBC 403OBP/955OPS 24HR 22MVP
38
3%
Dunn Adam 2004 CIN LF 1B 0 14 46HR 956 OPS 28MVP
17
1%
Carter Joe 1991 TOR 1B 1 16 BC 833OPS 33HR No TOR card 5MVP
35
3%
Nixon Otis 1991 BRV OF 0 17 371OBP 72SB
19
2%
Hidalgo Richard 2000 HOU OF 0 9 1028OPS 44HR 20MVP
15
1%
Figgins Chone 2009 ANG 3B 0 12 395OBP 42SB 10MVP
24
2%
Hudson Orlando 2007 AZ 2B 0 11 376OBP/817OPS GG
9
1%
Anson Cap 1884 CHC 1B 2 27 916OPS 102RBI LL
22
2%
Sauer Hank 1952 CHC LF 1 20 BC 37HR 892OPS 1MVP
30
2%
Davis Willie 1971 DOD CF 2 20 BC 16MVP GG Def=1 769OPS
30
2%
Longoria Evan 2009 TB 3B 0 9 889OPS 33HR 19MVP GG
32
3%
Donaldson Josh 2015 TOR 3B 0 6 939OPS 41HR 1MVP
40
3%
Burns George H 1926 CLV 1B 2 16 MMBC 394OBP/889OPS 64DB 1MVP
26
2%
Morneau Justin 2006 WAS/MIN 1B 0 14 934OPS 34HR 1MVP
26
2%
McCutchen Andrew 2012 PIT CF 0 8 404OBP/911OPS 1MVP
49
4%
Pendleton Terry 1991 BRV 3B 2 15 MBC 880OPS 1MVP
28
2%
Spiers Bill 1997 HOU 3B SS 0 13 919OPS
8
1%
Joyner Wally 1987 ANG 1B 1 16 BC 894OPS 13MVP
14
1%
Klesko Ryan 1999 BRV LF 1B 0 16 908OPS 9R
10
1%
Singleton Ken 1977 BAL/SLB OF DH 2 15 BC 438OBP/945OPS 24HR 3MVP
27
2%
DeJesus Ivan 1978 CHC SS 0 15 356OBP 41SB
15
1%
Tiernan Mike 1896 GIA OF 0 13 968OPS
16
1%
Piazza Mike 2000 NYM C 2 16 1012OPS 38HR 3MVP No NYM card
33
3%
Phillips Brandon 2011 CIN 2B 0 15 353OBP/810OPS GG
13
1%
Galarraga Andres 1993 COL 1B 3 19 370/403/602/1005 10MVP No COL Card
30
2%
Bell Jay 1999 AZ 2B 1 18 BC 931OPS 13MVP
19
2%
Jordan Brian 1998 STL OF 0 15 368OBP/902OPS 25HR
9
1%
Jenkins Geoff 2000 MIL OF 0 11 948OPS 34HR
10
1%
Zimmerman Ryan 2010 EXP/NAT 3B 0 12 .899 1e21 16MVP
9
1%
Lieberthal Mike 1999 PHI C 0 14 914OPS 31HR GG
22
2%
Castillo Luis 2003 FLA 2B 0 15 381OBP 21MVP GG 1e11
28
2%
Wynn Jimmy 1974 DOD OF 2 15 884OPS 32HR 5MVP No DOD card
26
2%
Sweeney Mike 2002 KCR 1B 0 16 417OBP/979OPS 24HR 20MVP
13
1%
Hunter Torii 2007 WAS/MIN CF 0 19 839OPS 28HR 15MVP GG
21
2%
Greer Rusty 1997 TEX OF 0 9 936OPS 26HR 22MVP
10
1%
Crawford Carl 2010 TB OF 0 15 851OPS 13TR LL 7MVP GG
23
2%
Wells Vernon 2003 TOR CF 0 15 909OPS 8MVP 33HR 49DB
20
2%
Ibanez Raul 2006 SEA LF 0 19 869OPS 33HR 21MVP
10
1%
Hodapp Johnny 1930 CLV 2B 0 9 386OBP/889OPS 51DB
35
3%
 
Total votes : 1236

  • Author
  • Message
Offline

Rosie2167

  • Posts: 1975
  • Joined: Mon Dec 23, 2013 5:55 pm

CLOSED - Batters Poll for ATG Card Add 16.2

PostThu Nov 03, 2016 3:34 pm

Please pick 10 Batters you'd like to see added to ATG. Top 10 + a few ties will get in.

Voting will be open through Wednesday, November 9.

Also you can refer to the Nominations string to see more detail on the players posted by the Ambassadors. Feel free to post links and other tidbits of info into this string as well.

I took two liberties in creating the list:
1) Removed Jesse Burkett from the list. The card included was a year he played for the Cleveland Spiders, which was not affiliated with the Indians.
2) Added in Derek Lee, 2003 FLA

I cut and paste the information from the master spreadsheet so apologies for the messiness, I was just trying to help expedite the voting process. Most of what you'll see next the players name is recognizable but here's the key...

Last Name, First Name, Year, Position, Franchise, Current Cards in ATG, Years of Career, Qualifications:

In those notes are a few acronyms:
BC = Better Card than whats in the current set
BRC = Better Representative Card than whats in the current set
MBRC = Much Better Representative Card than whats in the current set
MMBC = Much Much Better Representative Card than whats in the current set
#CY, #MVP = rank that year for those awards
A few Defensive ratings listed
I think everything else is pretty straightforward.

VOTE for 10!
Offline

BC15NY

  • Posts: 1263
  • Joined: Fri Sep 26, 2014 7:43 am

Re: Batters Poll for ATG Card Add 16.2

PostFri Nov 04, 2016 10:36 am

Evan Longoria needs your votes! Please help elect a Ray!
Offline

MARCPELLETIER

  • Posts: 1107
  • Joined: Thu Sep 06, 2012 11:27 pm

Re: Batters Poll for ATG Card Add 16.2

PostFri Nov 04, 2016 9:53 pm

I thought Hunt could crack the top10. It seems that we-Expos owners- will be stucked with Rodney Scott.
Offline

lanier64

  • Posts: 835
  • Joined: Fri Aug 24, 2012 3:02 am

Re: Batters Poll for ATG Card Add 16.2

PostFri Nov 04, 2016 11:58 pm

Rosie,

I thought you were going to put Texiera on the list?

Ed
Offline

Rosie2167

  • Posts: 1975
  • Joined: Mon Dec 23, 2013 5:55 pm

Re: Batters Poll for ATG Card Add 16.2

PostSun Nov 06, 2016 7:21 pm

lanier - I was looking in all the forums for where I mentioned Tex but can't find it. I recall throwing his name out but didn't gain the support from the Rangers forum. He definitely needs a card.
Offline

nels52

  • Posts: 352
  • Joined: Thu Aug 23, 2012 3:50 pm

Re: Batters Poll for ATG Card Add 16.2

PostSun Nov 06, 2016 10:58 pm

I would really push for '04 Beltran in perhaps addition to the great '03 Royals card. Baseball history! The '04 was the biggest trade piece imaginable and went on to a 38/42 with only 3 CS. 1 on defense. >>>8 HRs in postseason<<<< Only two rounds!!!! I know the 03 one, but in the 40/40 game, this is a milestone card. Massive baseball history too. Maybe double card beltran for double season phenom he is!!!! Highest SB% in baseball history. Might be a guy who hits .240 and guys don't complain.

'02 Hunter also cool----posterboy with B.Bonds in ASG doing a siiiick robbery.

'03 Marlins as a whole.


Good lists!
Offline

Radagast Brown

  • Posts: 2946
  • Joined: Sun Mar 17, 2013 7:25 pm

Re: Batters Poll for ATG Card Add 16.2

PostTue Nov 08, 2016 4:23 am

No love for Otis Nixon?
Offline

jawajedi

  • Posts: 34
  • Joined: Fri Sep 07, 2012 1:08 pm

Re: Batters Poll for ATG Card Add 16.2

PostTue Nov 08, 2016 2:32 pm

I totally agree with nels52 on the 2004 Beltran card!
Offline

visick

  • Posts: 5876
  • Joined: Thu Aug 23, 2012 5:25 pm
  • Location: Huntington Beach via NYC

Re: Batters Poll for ATG Card Add 16.2

PostWed Nov 09, 2016 6:37 pm

Does anybody have the defensive rating for Ron Hunt?

C'mon guys... NOBODY is going to use that card. It's a wasted pick.
Offline

visick

  • Posts: 5876
  • Joined: Thu Aug 23, 2012 5:25 pm
  • Location: Huntington Beach via NYC

Re: Batters Poll for ATG Card Add 16.2

PostWed Nov 09, 2016 7:12 pm

Sorry to vent here but we don't get enough additions.

EVERY pick matters.

If I'm not mistaken, he's a 4 @ 2B. Great another DH.
With an Injury.

But he should be cheap.

Well so is Joe Sewell...
Next

Return to --- ATG Card Discussions

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 11 guests