CLOSED - Pitchers Poll for ATG Card Add 16.2

Discussion for new cards to add; moderated by Rosie2167

Moderator: BC15NY

Pick 10 Pitchers

Poll ended at Thu Nov 10, 2016 3:30 pm

Mussina Mike 1995 BAL/SLB SP 1 18 10yrs wBAL noBAL card 1.069whip 19-9 5CY
43
4%
McDowell Sam 1965 CLV SP 2 15 325Ks 17MVP
39
3%
Peavy Jake 2007 SD SP 0 15 1.06whip 19-6, 1CY 7MVP
27
2%
Johnson Randy 1995 SEA SP 3 22 No SEA card, 1.05whip 18-2, 1CY 6MVP
41
4%
Lidge Brad 2004 HOU RP 0 11 .92 whip 29sv 8CY
37
3%
Putz JJ 2007 SEA RP 0 12 .69whip 40sv 13MVP
29
3%
Farrell Turk 1963 HOU SP 1 14 .97whip 12CG other card is RP for PHI
20
2%
Dotel Octavio 2002 HOU RP 0 15 .87whip
26
2%
Balfour Grant 2008 TB RP 0 15 .89whip
26
2%
Oswalt Roy 2006 HOU SP 1 14 1.17whip 15-8 4CY
12
1%
Schmidt Jason 2003 GIA SP 0 15 .95whip 17-5, 2CY 22MVP
24
2%
Hernandez Felix 2014 SEA SP 1 12 BC .92whip 15-6, 2CY 10MVP
36
3%
Mesa Jose 1995 CLV RP 0 20 1.03whip 2CY 4MVP 46sv
36
3%
Willis Dontrelle 2005 FLA SP 0 9 1.13whip 22-10, 2CY 11MVP
29
3%
Krukow Mike 1986 GIA SP 0 14 20-9, 1.06whip 3CY 15MVP
14
1%
Potter Nels 1945 BAL/SLB SP 0 14 1.10whip 21CG
15
1%
Hahn Noodles 1902 CIN SP 1 8 BC 1.06whip 23-12 36CG
25
2%
Betancourt Rafael 2007 CLV RP 0 13 .76whip
22
2%
Pettitte Andy 1997 NYY SP 0 18 1.24whip 18-7 5CY
32
3%
Carpenter Chris 2005 STL SP 0 15 1.06whip 17-4, 1CY 14MVP
34
3%
Webb Brandon 2006 AZ SP 0 7 1.13whip 16-8, 1CY
18
2%
Zito Barry 2002 A's SP 0 15 1.13whip 23-5, 1CY 13MVP
29
3%
Hentgen Pat 1996 TOR SP 0 14 1.25whip 20-10 1CY
8
1%
Dickey RA 2012 NYM SP 0 14 1.05whip 20-6, 1CY 14MVP
25
2%
Keuchel Dallas 2015 HOU SP 0 5 1.02whip 20-8, 1CY 5MVP
24
2%
Kluber Corey 2014 CLV SP 0 6 1.10whip 18-9, 1CY 11MVP
21
2%
Shantz Bobby 1952 A's SP 2 16 MBC 1.05whip 24-7 27CG 1MVP before CY
37
3%
Richard JR 1980 HOU SP 2 10 .92whip 10-4, Last season
45
4%
Donnelly Brendon 2003 ANG RP 0 9 1.07whip
8
1%
Wohlers Mark 1995 BRV RP 0 12 1.16whip 25sv
8
1%
Ryan BJ 2005 BAL/SLB RP 0 11 1.14whip 36sv
12
1%
Lee Bill C 1938 CHC SP 0 14 1.22whip 22-9, 9SHO 2MVP
17
1%
Bumgarner Madison 2013 GIA SP 0 8 1.03whip 13-9, 9CY
30
3%
Benitez Armando 1999 NYM RP 0 15 1.038whip 22 sv only 4HR given up
14
1%
Abernathy Ted 1967 CIN RP 1 18 MBC .978whip No Red Card
31
3%
Reed Steve 1995 COL RP 0 14 .98whip
5
0%
Kim Byung-Hyun 2002 AZ RP 0 9 1.07whip 36 sv
13
1%
Wainwright Adam 2010 STL SP 0 11 1.05whip 20-11, 2CY 17MVP
19
2%
Sorensen Larry 1978 MIL SP 0 12 1.17whip 18-12
5
0%
Vazquez Javier 2003 EXP/NAT SP 0 14 1.11whip 13-12
10
1%
Hamels Cole 2008 PHI SP 0 11 1.08whip 14-10
10
1%
Fernandez Jose 2013 FLA SP 0 4 .979whp 12-6, 1RoY 3CY
39
3%
Casey Hugh 1942 DOD RP 1 15 BC 1.21whip 13sv Led league 112 Inn
22
2%
Gubicza Mike 1988 KCR SP 0 14 1.19whip 20-8, 3CY
13
1%
Braxton Garland 1928 WAS/MIN SP 0 10 1.01whip 15CG
24
2%
Rogers Kenny 1995 TEX SP 1 20 1.28whip 17-7, only card is RP
20
2%
Shields James 2011 TB SP 0 11 1.04whip 16-12, 3CY 16MVP
11
1%
Eichhorn Mark 1986 TOR RP 0 15 157 INN 166 K .955whip 6CY 3RoY
36
3%
Bedrosian Steve 1987 PHI RP 2 15 1.20whip 40sv 1CY 16MVP
21
2%
Nagy Charles 1992 CLV SP 0 14 1.19whip 17-10 7CY
7
1%
 
Total votes : 1149

  • Author
  • Message
Offline

Rosie2167

  • Posts: 1975
  • Joined: Mon Dec 23, 2013 5:55 pm

CLOSED - Pitchers Poll for ATG Card Add 16.2

PostThu Nov 03, 2016 3:30 pm

Please pick 10 Pitchers you'd like to see added to ATG. Top 10 + a few ties will get in.

Voting will be open through Wednesday, November 9.

Also you can refer to the Nominations string to see more detail on the players posted by the Ambassadors. Feel free to post links and other tidbits of info into this string as well.

I took two liberties in creating the list:
1) Included Bedrosian's 87 CY year in place of another Mariners pitcher. There are 3 already and I was reaching to find the last one, so in goes Steve.
2) Added Charles Nagy as the Indians Pitcher nomination, 14yrs no card and hadn't received any direction from the Indians forum.

I cut and paste the information from the master spreadsheet so apologies for the messiness, I was just trying to help expedite the voting process. Most of what you'll see next the players name is recognizable but here's the key...

Last Name, First Name, Year, Position, Franchise, Current Cards in ATG, Years of Career, Qualifications:

In those notes are a few acronyms:
BC = Better Card than whats in the current set
BRC = Better Representative Card than whats in the current set
MBRC = Much Better Representative Card than whats in the current set
MMBC = Much Much Better Representative Card than whats in the current set
#CY, #MVP = rank that year for those awards
I think everything else is pretty straightforward.

VOTE for 10!
Offline

STEVE F

  • Posts: 4253
  • Joined: Tue Mar 19, 2013 2:08 pm

Re: Pitchers Poll for ATG Card Add 16.2

PostThu Nov 03, 2016 5:19 pm

Most notable ommision, to me, is 63 Dick Ellsworth. Wasn't he close last time? In any case , he'll be my top priority nomination in the next round!
Offline

FRANKMANSUETO

  • Posts: 5126
  • Joined: Thu Aug 23, 2012 5:59 pm

Re: Pitchers Poll for ATG Card Add 16.2

PostFri Nov 04, 2016 10:24 am

Don't forget to VOTE ROW SP* Jake Peavy!

2007 Jake Peavy: Cy Young Season.
http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/90444/2007/1/2007
Offline

BC15NY

  • Posts: 1259
  • Joined: Fri Sep 26, 2014 7:43 am

Re: Pitchers Poll for ATG Card Add 16.2

PostFri Nov 04, 2016 10:34 am

Andy Pettitte needs your votes! Fill out the ticket with a vote for Grant Balfour!
Offline

Sheikyerboudi

  • Posts: 247
  • Joined: Sat Aug 25, 2012 5:33 am
  • Location: California High Desert

Re: Pitchers Poll for ATG Card Add 16.2

PostFri Nov 04, 2016 1:31 pm

I looked through a lot of these pitcher cards trying to find cards that I would actually use. A lot of the relievers are those "1" endurance awesome cards that you ALWAYS see in the FA pile when the season begins. I could not find many SP who had awe-inspiring cards. However I found one nugget in all this that I would definately use :

http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/33652/1660/1/60

I'm sure most of you just skipped past this guy - but look at the '63 card and tell me you wouldn't use it!!! The name isn't sexy, but the card is.

- The Sheik
Offline

Rosie2167

  • Posts: 1975
  • Joined: Mon Dec 23, 2013 5:55 pm

Re: Pitchers Poll for ATG Card Add 16.2

PostFri Nov 04, 2016 4:11 pm

Sheik - Good pull! I wish I had time to post all the links to cards that existed. I agree, Farrell is very usable.
Offline

djp_77

  • Posts: 357
  • Joined: Fri Aug 31, 2012 3:08 am

Re: Pitchers Poll for ATG Card Add 16.2

PostSat Nov 05, 2016 1:03 am

http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/3235/1690/1/90

The 1995 Randy Johnson is his best card. At Wrigley's 18/18 18/18 ballpark I put in all three cards.

BA - OBP - SLG - OPS

2001
L - 0.036 0.098 0.071 0.169
R - 0.117 0.174 0.182 0.356

1999
L - 0.000 0.074 0.000 0.074
R - 0.152 0.175 0.307 0.482

1995
L - 0.000 0.046 0.000 0.046
R - 0.117 0.166 0.182 0.348

Return to --- ATG Card Discussions

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 8 guests