Deja Vu League -- Season 28

Unlikely Champ is rebuilding, he needed a CF upgrade over McCutchen, and dealt from depth (also has Arenado, J.Ramirez, Villar), his team looks pretty loaded.

OK, I stand corrected -- not rebuilding. But I still like the deal anyhow

Unlikely Champ is rebuilding, he needed a CF upgrade over McCutchen, and dealt from depth (also has Arenado, J.Ramirez, Villar), his team looks pretty loaded.

OK, I stand corrected -- not rebuilding. But I still like the deal anyhow

I never questioned the deal itself, perhaps you quoted the wrong person/quote

Old rosters updated for latest trades at https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... =986916125

See new retro keeper at viewtopic.php?f=11&t=642253

since we're weighing in...the change in Reelin' to same order as FA draft for prospects, worst to first, not serpentine was overdue. it makes no sense that a playoff team may ALSO have a chance, and often does get a top prospect pick, while a team finishing last or near the bottom in the west, might also, and often does get stuck with a 10-12 prospect pick. in what league in what sport is a draft order determined that way? those picks that just got traded for the top homerun hitter and mvp candidate donaldson could easily be 12 and 13. since there's no way of knowing where tc's team will finish with a combined record in this year's two seasons, there's an already an element of chance, but at least when you make a trade for prospects, you have some idea whether the team you're dealing with is likely to have a top five or bottom 5 record. but that's secondary to what I believe is the bigger flaw...allowing already successful teams to possibly have higher picks than teams already struggling.

while changing determining the order likely won't happen, at least now...i do agree with lakeview dave that if we're gonna do random and serpentine for prospect draft, that order should be determined as soon as the 2nd season ends, so we know the value of prospect picks we own or want to trade for

CURRENT RULE

Prospect draft sequence will be random and serpentine.

PROPOSED CHANGE, to be effective immediately

Prospect draft sequence will be worst-record first, NFL style, based on the combined win-loss records of the 2 seasons for each card set.

1. tcochran - Worst-first
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.

Can't cut and paste from phone, but vote worst to 1st

CURRENT RULE

Prospect draft sequence will be random and serpentine.

PROPOSED CHANGE, to be effective immediately

Prospect draft sequence will be worst-record first, NFL style, based on the combined win-loss records of the 2 seasons for each card set.

1. tcochran - Worst-first
2. alk58 - Worst-first
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.

CURRENT RULE

Prospect draft sequence will be random and serpentine.

PROPOSED CHANGE, to be effective immediately

Prospect draft sequence will be worst-record first, NFL style, based on the combined win-loss records of the 2 seasons for each card set.

1. tcochran - Worst-first
2. alk58 - Worst-first
3. Meat - Worst-first
4. Dr. Publix - random, serpentine
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.