Summer - Winter Keeper League - SEASON 30

{{PROSPECT ROUND 2}}
1. tcochran (from lakeviewdave) - Derek Fisher OF HOU
2. willmurr24 Mickey Moniak OF PHILS
3. tpiercersn - Carson Kelly C STL
4. knight1 - Eric Thames 1B MIL
5, Ninersphan - Ben Gamel OF SEA
6. damien666 - Yadier Alvarez RHP LAD
7. ironwill1 - Hunter Greene SP Cin
8. kihoover - Nick Senzel, 3B, Cin
9. tcochran - Paul DeJong 2B/SS STL
10. JMP1 - Mitch Keller SP PIT
11. denorien
12. willmurr24 (from jflatour99)

{{PROSPECT ROUND 3}}
1.knight1 (from lakeviewdave)
2. willmurr24
3. tpiercersn
4. knight1
5, Ninersphan
6. lakeviewdave (from damien666)
7. ironwill1
8. kihoover
9. tcochran
10. JMP1
11. denorien
12. tpiercersn (from jflatour99)

I believe H Greene is not eligible signed on July 7th[list=][/list]

Score one point for the other Bill Murray!

{{PROSPECT ROUND 2}}
1. tcochran (from lakeviewdave) - Derek Fisher OF HOU
2. willmurr24 Mickey Moniak OF PHILS
3. tpiercersn - Carson Kelly C STL
4. knight1 - Eric Thames 1B MIL
5, Ninersphan - Ben Gamel OF SEA
6. damien666 - Yadier Alvarez RHP LAD
7. ironwill1 - RE-PICK - GREENE NOT ELIGIBLE
8. kihoover - Nick Senzel, 3B, Cin
9. tcochran - Paul DeJong 2B/SS STL
10. JMP1 - Mitch Keller SP PIT
11. denorien
12. willmurr24 (from jflatour99)

{{PROSPECT ROUND 3}}
1.knight1 (from lakeviewdave)
2. willmurr24
3. tpiercersn
4. knight1
5, Ninersphan
6. lakeviewdave (from damien666)
7. ironwill1
8. kihoover
9. tcochran
10. JMP1
11. denorien
12. tpiercersn (from jflatour99)

{{PROSPECT ROUND 2}}
1. tcochran (from lakeviewdave) - Derek Fisher OF HOU
2. willmurr24 Mickey Moniak OF PHILS
3. tpiercersn - Carson Kelly C STL
4. knight1 - Eric Thames 1B MIL
5, Ninersphan - Ben Gamel OF SEA
6. damien666 - Yadier Alvarez RHP LAD
7. ironwill1 - RE-PICK - GREENE NOT ELIGIBLE
8. kihoover - Nick Senzel, 3B, Cin
9. tcochran - Paul DeJong 2B/SS STL
10. JMP1 - Mitch Keller SP PIT
11. denorien - Adrian Morejon SP SD
12. willmurr24 (from jflatour99)

{{PROSPECT ROUND 3}}
1.knight1 (from lakeviewdave)
2. willmurr24
3. tpiercersn
4. knight1
5, Ninersphan
6. lakeviewdave (from damien666)
7. ironwill1
8. kihoover
9. tcochran
10. JMP1
11. denorien
12. tpiercersn (from jflatour99)

Looking for a pick in 3rd round. If interested in trading, let's talk.

Greene signed before the draft started.

Ironwill, see pm

Sun Jul 16, 2017 8:11 pm
{{PROSPECT ROUND 2}}
1. tcochran (from lakeviewdave) - Derek Fisher OF HOU
2. willmurr24 Mickey Moniak OF PHILS
3. tpiercersn - Carson Kelly C STL
4. knight1 - Eric Thames 1B MIL
5, Ninersphan - Ben Gamel OF SEA
6. damien666 - Yadier Alvarez RHP LAD
7. ironwill1 - RE-PICK - GREENE NOT ELIGIBLE
8. kihoover - Nick Senzel, 3B, Cin
9. tcochran - Paul DeJong 2B/SS STL
10. JMP1 - Mitch Keller SP PIT
11. denorien - Adrian Morejon SP SD
12. willmurr24 Bo Bichette SS TOR)

{{PROSPECT ROUND 3}}
1.knight1 (from lakeviewdave)
2. willmurr24
3. tpiercersn
4. knight1
5, Ninersphan
6. lakeviewdave (from damien666)
7. ironwill1
8. kihoover
9. tcochran
10. JMP1
11. denorien
12. tpiercersn (from jflatour99)
Top

JMP1

Posts: 1666
Joined: Thu Aug 23, 2012 4:30 pm
Re

I believe H Greene is not eligible signed on July 7th[list=][/list]

Score one point for the other Bill Murray!

Greene was signed on July 7th, this draft started on July 14th. He would be eligible under the rules.

2) Each team will be able to select 4 prospects, defined as any player who: a) DID NOT RECEIVE A CARD for the current season; b) does not appear on TSN's website; and
c) is the property of an MLB team. In other words, no, those who have not yet signed as of the start of that year's draft are not eligible for the prospect draft.

Since the Prospect draft is the only draft that signing would be an issue, a player signed before the start of that draft would be eligible.
Greene is in.

Posts: 243
Joined: Thu Aug 23, 2012 3:08 pm
Re: Summer - Winter Keeper League


Fri Jul 14, 2017 11:36 am
lakeviewdave wrote:
If it were not prior to the MLB Draft, then players like Mickey Moniak, Nick Senzel, Riley Pint, etc. could have been drafted last year, but they were not.

In last year's prospect draft, players from 2015 MLB were drafted, Benintendi, Swanson, B.Rodgers, etc.

Given that, it would have to be prior to this year's MLB draft which occurred in early June.


We need Terry to weigh in. That Appel and Gray were drafted in our league as prospects a few weeks after the amateur draft in 2013 is a matter of record. I don't recall the rules changing between 2013 and now. That Mickey Moniak, Nick Senzel, and Riley Pint weren't drafted last year is because no one took them. If they were under contract, they were eligible. JF, what do you recall?
Top

tcochran

Posts: 7169
Joined: Thu Aug 23, 2012 3:23 pm
Re: Summer - Winter Keeper League


Fri Jul 14, 2017 11:41 am
It appears to me that "those who have not yet signed as of the start of that year's draft are not eligible for the prospect draft" is referring only to this league, since there is no mention of MLB.

Since "that year's draft" and "the prospect draft" are both used in that sentence, I infer that it is the start of the FA draft that would be the effective date required for prospect signing.

After all that parsing, I feel downright rabbinical!