Sat Aug 05, 2017 7:49 pm
I agree with keyzick. With so much overbooking, what's the point of league assignments at all...people can still "cherry pick" if they choose to.
I question whether cherry-picking was ever really a significant problem anyway, especially since divisions became randomized. The real problem was a lack of hard deadlines, so people would wait forever to join a league. In any case, with increased overbooking, the cherry-picking "problem" is no longer even "solved".
So why not, as keyzick suggests, simplify things and return to "first come-first served". Just create new leagues as they fill. That system, combined with hard deadlines, has worked fine for Moose and the Barnstormers Tour for years.