17.3 Run Off Poll - Until Thursday 9pm PT

To fill our last two spots for the 17.3 add please choose 2 of the following players to get in. Voting will close this Thursday at 9pm PT.

thanks
Rosie

Rob* Murphy 1986 CIN RP 0 11 0.93w
http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/38677/1986/1/101
Bill Mueller 2003 BOS 3B 2B 0 11 0.938 MVP-12 SS 2e21 1R INJ+
Greg Vaughn 1998 SD LF 1 15 MBC 272/363/597/960 MVP-4 SS 50HR New Franch
http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/3060/1690/1/90
George Sisler 1922 SLB 1B 2 15 420/467/594/1061 1e18 MVP-1
Harry Heilmann 1923 DET RF 1B 2 17 403/481/632/1113 MVP-3 INJ+
Kemp Matt 2011 DOD CF 0 12 324/399/586/986 MVP-2 GG 1-2e5 AA (19-14)17
http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/597/2011/1/3011
Francisco* Liriano 2006 MIN SP/RP 0 12 1.00whip ROY-3
Richard Hidalgo 2000 HOU OF 0 9 314/391/636/1028 MVP-20
Robinson Cano 2012 NYY 2B 1 13 313/379/550/929 MVP-4 GG SS 1e6 INJ-0 8R
http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/182/2012/1/3012

okay lets go people!

Cano, HH and Sissy imo would be the guys who will play at all caps- even IF they get priced on the higher side for these cards, would still bet they get a lot of use- although I'm going to look at Hidalgo and Murphy just to make sure I haven't missed something. (okay, so as I thought, cant see either of those unfortunately)

Top numbers are at petco 1/1/1/1 and the bottom numbers are wrigley 18/18/18/18
Categories
BA OBP SLG OPS RC/27 BR NERP

George Sisler 1922 1e18
0.501 0.538 0.687 1.225 20.00 19.48 28.54
0.566 0.598 0.778 1.376 28.90 24.94 33.04

0.552 0.585 0.763 1.349 26.93 23.94 32.24
0.617 0.645 0.855 1.499 38.80 29.41 36.75

Harry Heilmann 1923 - rf/lf 2(0)e14 cf-3e14 1b-3e16
0.545 0.616 0.866 1.483 31.65 27.62 35.39
0.476 0.559 0.755 1.314 21.77 21.95 30.63

0.647 0.703 1.137 1.840 61.18 39.09 45.56
0.579 0.645 1.026 1.672 42.49 33.42 40.80

Murphy awfully good, and lefty relievers are as rare as hens teeth in these unlimited live drafts.

Murphy awfully good, and lefty relievers are as rare as hens teeth in these unlimited live drafts.

not disagreeing on that-- just haven't seen the card, but a very defensible choice and reasoning.

http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/38677/1986/1/101

Cool-

clearly Murphy is a good card that will get used.

IF you have Hidalgo and can post that it would be great...

Also DJP-- If you could post numbers on Greg Vaughn and Hidalgo (which I haven't seen) think it would become pretty obvious what the difference in their cards will be.

I'm sure some yahoo is voting Vaughn just to get under my skin, but god almighty, please think about the fact that hes not going to get used anywhere above 110 mil or so, and even that is giving him the benefit of assuming he'll be priced on the lower end for his card.

I tried to take a photo of Hidalgo card, but I don't know how to post it here.

Voted for Cano and Heilmann

Vaughn's card offensively is available from the 90's mystery game and is nothing to get excited about. Certainly not a high cap card.

I tried to take a photo of Hidalgo card, but I don't know how to post it here.

Any idea why his card is getting so many votes?
hoping that its a lot better than I anticipate.