Players with ZERO Cards Nominations

John Valentin had a few very good seasons for the Red Sox

I won't limit:
1915 Ernie Shore
1928 Garland Broxton
1929 Taylor Douthit
1933 Billy Rogell
1942 Wally Judnich
1944 Nels Potter

I second the vote for these.

Garland Broxton is really Garland Braxton.

1919 Hod Eller
1904 or 05 Bob Wicker
1914 or 15 Nick Cullop
1960 Frank Baumann
1985 Don Carman
1930 Joe Stripp
1932 Fred Schulte
1992 Darryl Hamilton
1937 Myril Hoag
1897 Jimmy Callahan
1914 Rebel Oakes
1974 Buzz Capra
1974 Charlie Williams
1901 Bill Keister
1999 Troy O'Leary
2003 Jay Payton
1971 Don Wilson

Ivan Dejesus..

I know many of you play that unlimited salary crap, I will even do it once in a while in the winter, but I prefer the 80-100 million dollar leagues...I would like to see more 70s, 80s, and 90s players.

Walt "no neck" Williams, John Castino (rookie), George Mitterwald, Mike Epstein, Mike Kekich, Steve Kemp, a good Deron Johnson and a good Cesar Tovar.

2016 Mookie Betts
2004 J. D Drew
2011 Jacoby Ellsbury
1996 Bernard Gilkey
2003 Marcus Giles
2006 Kris Bryant
2007 Curtis Granderson
2010 Brett Gardner
2008 Nick Markakis
2017 Jose Altuve
2015 Kevin Kiermaier
2009 Ryan Zimmermann

Full disclosure: all of these hitters w/o ATG cards are derived from the baseball-reference.com Single Season WAR leaders page. All have single-season WAR between 9.5and 7.0. Most have had substantial careers, with several still active.

A few more players, beginning with pitchers:

1996 Roberto Hernandez
1904 Jake Weimer
1998 Orlando Hernandez
1998 Graham Lloyd
1997 Bob Wickman

A few hitters, historic in different ways
2004 Hideki Matsui
2001 Miguel Cairo (played five positions: 54763)
1963 Phl Linz (played six! positions 654897--and the harmonica, a year later, when he played just 5 pos., hence 1963)
1993 Joe Girardi
1965 Charlie Lau (career OPS+ 89, but 120 in this season).