2018 Mystery Tournament - comments & complaints

I vote for no-DH in the 70's, evens the tourney out more.

I'm for the 70's with DH.

No DH 70"s

I vote to use the DH for the 70s but don't have a strong preference either way.
Thanks to franky for starting the tournament.

I vote NO DH for '70s.
Rob

I'd prefer no DH for the 70's. I think it balances the tournament. You have to manage differently with and without the DH, so I'd prefer the even split.

We are not going to decide on 70s DH purely on a democratic voting basis. For 70s DH to prevail, there has to be a strong majority for it. Otherwise, we'll remain no DH because that is the traditional format and I'm a traditional commissioner. Next year's commissioner may run things differently.

Id prefer no dh but looks like the people have spoken. Strat baseball is so much better without the dh but I also agree that Hal often doesn't follow sound logic relative to no dh so am fine with whatever you all decide

At this point, the rules will stay no-DH in the 70s. No 70s DH is the traditional rule and the rule that has been posted since the start of this tournament. I am extremely reluctant to change anything from the traditional format, but since last year broke with tradition and had 70s DH, I was willing to listen to the 70s DH supporters and if there was overwhelming support for 70s DH I would have switched it. But the support has not been overwhelming; there continues to be a substantial percentage that favors no DH in the 70s. A close call, but it will stay no-DH.

No DH for 70's???? I'm out!!!!!

At this point, the rules will stay no-DH in the 70s. No 70s DH is the traditional rule and the rule that has been posted since the start of this tournament. I am extremely reluctant to change anything from the traditional format, but since last year broke with tradition and had 70s DH, I was willing to listen to the 70s DH supporters and if there was overwhelming support for 70s DH I would have switched it. But the support has not been overwhelming; there continues to be a substantial percentage that favors no DH in the 70s. A close call, but it will stay no-DH.