Third Basemen 18.1

please suggest Third basemen prior to 1990 for inclusion in the 18.1 vote

1986 Mike Schmidt -- MVP, .290/.390/.547, eligible at 1B, 6L http://365.strat-o-matic.com/player/40700/1986/1/101

1954 Eddie Mathews -- .290/.423/.603, career high ops+

1929 Pinky Whitney -- .327/.390/.482, 43 2bs, 14 3bs, better card than what we have

1976 Graig Nettles led AL w/32hr...split vs rhp .317/.390/.597/.987

1924 Specs Toporcer STL L 5R 3b-4e12, 2b-4e65, SS-4e52 313/362/409 1920's Cardinals 3b, good platoon option
1948 Bobby Brown NYY L 3R 3b-4e27, SS-4e52, 2b-4e41 300/383/405 Needs a better card
1970 Tommy Harper MIL R 1R 3b-4e31, 2b4e34, LF-2(+1)8, RF-3 296/377/522 Would be his BEST card by a lot
1940 Buddy Lewis WASH L E 3b-4e32, OF-4(-2)12 317/393/443 Needs better card
1986 Gary Gaetti MIN R 4L 3b-2e22, SS-4e48, 2b-4e41 287/347/518 Needs better card
1939 Cookie Lavagetto BKN R E 3b-2e24 300/387/416 Needs better card
1931 Joe Stripp CIN R 1L 3b-3e25, 1b-4e17 324/359/415 A New Addition
1923 Pie Traynor PIT R E 3b-1e26, SS-3e57 338/377/489 Would be his best card

Buddy Lewis was an All-Star for the mid 30's/early 40's Senators. They need some help and he needs a more representative card.

Toporcer and Stripp would be new players to Strat

1953 Hank Thompson. Has been mentioned in previous polls.
.302 .400 .567

Yep you beat me to it...
Hubie Brooks 1981 NYM 3B LF/RF 0 15 756ops (3e37) (4-1e11) ROY-3
Graig Nettles* 1976 NYY 3B 3 22 254/327/475/802 MVP-16
Hank Thompson* 1953 NYG 3B RF 1 9 BC 302/400/567/969 3B(3e21) RF(4+1e7)
Heine Zimmerman 1912 CHC 3B 1B 1 13 MBC 372/418/571/989 MVP-6 INJ+
Luis Salazar 1980 SDP 3B/OF 2 13 337/7 triples in 169 ABs. Utility type guy with speed
Pie Traynor 1923 PIT 3B 2 17 338/377/489/866/19 triples LL
George Brett* 1976 KC 3B 4 21 333/377/462/839/MVP-2/first batting title in a yr when no one hit at all

Love 1976 Nettles - thank you for posting his splits. Assuming he's a 1 I think that might make him playable at all caps.

Frank Home Run Baker's best year is 1912
.347/.404/.541/.945 This is an OPS+ of 174.
I don't know what his fielding rating is, but of AL thirdbasemen that year who played more than 1000 innings at third, he has the best RF/G and Fielding Percentage.

Nettles 3b-2e19
Baker 3b-2e34

1912 Frank Baker. BA OBP SLG OPS RC/27 BR NERP

Petco 1/1/1/1
0.412 0.461 0.658 1.118 13.90 15.11 25.47
0.406 0.455 0.648 1.103 13.39 14.57 25.02

Wrigley 18/18/18/18
0.472 0.516 0.769 1.285 20.28 20.97 30.47
0.466 0.510 0.760 1.270 19.58 20.43 30.02

Eric Soderholm 1977 White Sox
Butch Hobson 1977 Red Sox