Sun Nov 04, 2018 4:24 pm
I think we're all basically saying the same thing. The ratio of the Dow in '78 to today is almost exactly that of the ratio of players' salaries in '78 to today. We used to deplore the atmosphere at playoff baseball games because the corporations had snagged up the good seats -- people with no connection to the teams were there to be seen not to be heard. That is the atmosphere at many major league games today, precisely because of that corporate money. Ticket prices for the best seats at most MLB stadiums in 1978 was about $5.00; today....obscene (maybe not $150 obscene if we follow the 30/1 ratio). Thank heavens for Stubhub (which comes mostly from corporate season tickets I would think). Your point about cable tv is well taken, but again I would argue that it cuts off many people from the day to day enjoyment of fandom by imposing yet another financial burden.
One point I forgot to make in my last post was the nostalgic quality of baseball for some kind of rural roots (the pasture-like quality, the slow pace of the game reflecting small town time...). And yet, major league baseball has always been played exclusively in large cities. The early teams may have had rural "hicks" and "rubes" filling their lineups, but they also had incredibly large numbers of first and second generation immigrants from the cities (baseball as source of integration). One of the first major shifts in baseball occurs around 1920 (ironically just after the 1919 scandal in which big city gamblers were seen as the root of the cancer) when the lively ball was introduced. I think that it is not for nothing that 1920 marks the first time in American history that more than 50% of the population lived in big cities. The slow pace of the game was already being eroded by the splash and glitter of the big bopper, the glamor of the home run. What we are witnessing today perhaps is the suburbanization of the game: parents who have the means to give their children the access to the best materials to play the game, at the cost of losing the "soul" (whatever that may be) of the game.
I'm not arguing for a return to a by-gone era (as much as I would love to); the genie is out of the bottle. The instant gratification demanded by today's audiences imposes the BB/SO/HR scenario. We see this everywhere: I see it in the cut-and-paste attitude of "writing" papers amongst my students or the glazed look in their eyes when I ask them to read, "really read" a text or "really look at" an image. We need to fill time, we are afraid of time...something that baseball never was.