19.1 Results

Here are the voting results for 19.1.
Top 25 are in and will be sent to Strat today.
Next 10 (2% of vote) are back for 19.2 voting.
Final 15 are out.

Year/Player/Team/Pos/Votes/Pct

2017 Jose Altuve HOU 2b 111 4
1995 Edgar Martinez SEA DH 110 4
1981 Nolan Ryan Astros SP 109 4
2012 Miguel Cabrera Det 3b/1b 99 4
1954 Ted Kluszewski Reds 1B 98 3
1899 John McGraw Bal 3B 91 3
1963 Hank Aaron MIL RF 91 3
1996 Alex Rodriguez Sea SS 83 3
1972 Carlton Fisk BOS C 82 3
1937 Joe DiMaggio NYY CF 78 3
2000 Ivan Rodriguez Texas C 74 3
1979 Oscar Gamble Tex/NYY OF 73 3
1888 Silver King StL RHP 71 3
1986 Hubie Brooks MON SS 69 2
2014 Adam Wainwright STL SP 67 2
2011 Cole Hamels Phillies SP 65 2
2017 Max Scherzer WAS SP 69 2
1980 Don Sutton LAN 67 2
1970 Jim Perry MIN SP 64 2
1966 Willie Stargell PIT OF/1b 63 2
1950 Eddie Yost WSH 3B 61 2
2011 Jose Bautista Tor RF/3b 65 2
1969 Don Kessinger Cubs SS 57 2
1920 Happy Felsch CWS CF 53 2
1971 Steve Mingori Indians LHRP 53 2
------------------------------------------------
1954 Yogi Berra NYY C/3B 52 2
1968 Stan Bahnsen NYY SP 50 2
1967 Orlando Cepeda STL 1B 50 2
1993 Paul Molitor Toronto 1b 48 2
1991 Otis Nixon ATL OF 49 2
1969 Andy Messersmith Angels SP/RP 45 2
1990 Dave Magadan Mets 1b/3b 44 2
1970 Alex Johnson CAL LF 44 2
1952 Ferris Fain PHA 1b 43 2
1964 Bob Allison MIN OF/1B 43 2
--------------------------------------
2010 Carlos Ruiz PHI C 37 1
1999 Rey Ordonez NYM SS 38 1
1973 Fred Beene NYY SP/RP 32 1
1894 Tuck Turner PHI OF 32 1
1922 Charlie Hollocher CHC ss 31 1
1919 Hod Eller Reds SP 29 1
2015 Jeurys Familia NYM RP 29 1
2011 Ian Kinsler TEX 2B 29 1
1894 Lave Cross PHI SS/3b 29 1
1950 Art Houtteman DET SP/RP 25 1
1883 Jim Whitney BOS SP 24 1
2005 Jonny Gomes TB OF 25 1
1884 Fleetwood Walker Toledo C 22 1
2013 JJ Hardy BAL SS 21 1
1993 Jeff Blauser Atl SS 15 1

Thanks, Bill, for putting this together! Just about a quarter of the guys who got in are from the 2010s, a little over a quarter from the 60s and 70s, 8% from before 1900, 8% from the 20s and 30s. A little bummed that Yogi and the Baby Bull didn't get just a bit more love, but there are some good cards about to hit (looking forward to the Aaron card).

Thanks to all who voted for my all-time favorite player, Don Sutton.

Thanks, Bill, for putting this together! Just about a quarter of the guys who got in are from the 2010s, a little over a quarter from the 60s and 70s, 8% from before 1900, 8% from the 20s and 30s. A little bummed that Yogi and the Baby Bull didn't get just a bit more love, but there are some good cards about to hit (looking forward to the Aaron card).

You're welcome! Looks like it could turn out to be a very good add; let's see how they are all priced.

We should ban the bottom 15 miserable failures for five years before they can be selected to waste votes on again. Didn't vote for any of them. Still hoping Otis Nixon stays around, people just don't seem to get his small ball value Glad to see my nominee was, once again, the leading vote getter. Don't forget Aaron Judge (2017) will also be in this add, courtesy of yours truly...

im happy we finally get leadoff maestro McGraw in and the Cabrera card is a good thing too.
that Altuve card jury is out on- but still not a bad thing.

Wow. Thought Familia would get some more votes especially in franchise mode where he would be the Mets all time closer.

Nice to see Eddie Yost's best year finally getting some attention.

I saw this too late to vote, but I am super-psyched to see 1979 Oscar Gamble get in!

Any idea when the new cards will be added to the set?

Any idea when the new cards will be added to the set?

Should be added by the end of the month.

Thanks,
Bill