I am not sure if re-picking would be fair. I have been able to see guys this year. I understand that it is early but I would pick a guy for next year hoping he stays hot. I would suggest a supplemental pick in the round I took Treinen. I will go with whatever though. My dog in the fight is I would pick a player doing well this year. That would be an advange I think. I also believe I am the one that messed up so if you don't want to give the extra pick I am good with also
Mike
Not the commissioner, but I have played one on TV. The way I have handled this type of situation in the past is similar to what you describe. IMHO, you should have to play this year with 39. and not be allowed any "benefit" from a mistake that had been pointed out to you. You get to go back to 40 players in the normal course of next years draft.
Please check your rosters. I've updated the google roster sheet and it looks good except for two owners: chasenally and Mr Baseball World have 39 players on their roster. I think chase only has 39 because of a past mistake, but MBW should have 40. I've gone through the draft and trades and cannot find the missing player. Please check your rosters to make sure they are correct.