2019 Mystery Tournament - Final 12 Voting

Item 1- 1st choice - 60s; 2nd choice - 80s
Item 2- Partial live draft
Item 3- no unique stadiums
Item 4- $80 M cap
Item 5- DH used for 90s, 80s, 70s but not for 60s
Item 6- allow repeat stadiums
Item 7- divisions - seeded

unofficially, SteadyEddy has missed out and JimmyC has qualified for the last spot in finals. Seven votes are in and repeat stadiums have been allowed 7-0! Since repeat stadiums always win in a landslide, we should probably eliminate this vote. All of items 4-7 are headed toward the same conclusions as the commissioner before some discontent objected to eliminating these questions. The 80 mil cap, 60s-no DH, 70s-80s-90s-DH, and seeded divisions all have 6 votes; one more vote will lock these in. Live draft is leading 6-1 while unique stadiums is leading 5-2. The decade vote is close: 60s (6 points), 70s (7 pts), 80s (4 pts), 90s (4 pts).

Item 1- 1st choice - 80s; 2nd choice - 90s
Item 2- autodraft
Item 3- no unique stadiums
Item 4- $80 M cap
Item 5- DH for all sets
Item 6- allow repeat stadiums
Item 7- divisions - seeded

still need votes from AdamKatz, mburatti, hallerose, and (unofficially) JimmyC. The decade vote is very close.

Item 1- 1st choice is 70's DH only; 2nd choice is 80's. 70s without DH is terrible.
Item 2- auto draft
Item 3- stadiums do not have to be unique. - when people are saying "Allow" unique stadiums, I am not sure if that means that it is ok to use the same unique stadium, or that everyone must have a unique stadium. Not sure how close the vote is, but that maybe should be clarified.
Item 4- $80M cap
Item 5- DH
Item 6- repeat stadiums - commish says that you can repeat stadiums, so no vote.
Item 7- I do not see a reason to seed divisions-the top 12 are not necessarily the best players in that order (except the first seed), but commish seems to say there will be seeding without vote. If there is a vote, I say random is fine.

from the initial posts in this thread

Voting Item 3. Do you want to have "Unique Stadiums" in the finals? Having Unique Stadiums means that we cannot have two teams in the final 12 league that are using the same stadium. If one team is using Yankee Stadium, no one else can have Yankee Stadium as their ballpark. If Autodraft is chosen, and Unique Stadiums is chosen, we'll have a quick stadium draft on the discussion forum based on final standings (1-12). If we vote for a partial live draft, we will make it mandatory to draft a ballpark as part of the live draft.

We have now approved - repeat stadiums allowed, DH in 70s,80s,90s; 80 mil cap; seeded divisions. Still undecided: 60s DH is 6/3; live/auto draft is 6/3; unique stadiums is 5/4; decade (unofficially) is 60s (6 points), 70s (9 pts), 80s (7 pts), 90s (5 pts).

still need votes from mburatti, hallerose, and (unofficially) JimmyC.

Item 1- 1st choice - 70's; 2nd choice - 80's
Item 2- Partial live draft
Item 3- unique stadiums
Item 4- $80 M cap
Item 5- No DH 60's, 70's, DH 80's, 90's
Item 6- allow repeat stadiums
Item 7- divisions - seeded

ok, so it will be a live draft, DH; either 70s or 80s

hallerose and Jimmy - we need your votes on decade and unique stadia

Was going to wait until I was official, but here goes:

Item 1- 1st choice - 70's; 2nd choice - 80's
Item 2- Partial live draft
Item 3- unique stadiums
Item 4- $80 M cap
Item 5- No DH 60's, DH 70's, 80's, 90's
Item 6- allow repeat stadiums
Item 7- divisions - seeded

Item 1- 1st choice - 90's; 2nd choice - 70's
Item 2- Partial live draft
Item 3- unique stadiums
Item 4- $80 M cap
Item 5- DH for all
Item 6- allow repeat stadiums
Item 7- random