Tue Mar 31, 2020 2:03 pm
I remember reading in Earl Weaver's autobiography that as a minor league manager in the Orioles system, he administered IQ tests to all the players on his team. He found that Dalkowski's IQ was well below average and decided that Dalkowski simple couldn't process all the advice he was getting from his coaches.
He decided to simplify the problem for his player. He kept telling Dalkowski: "Just throw fastballs for strikes, aiming for the the center of the plate. Don't worry about anything else." Weaver reasoned that with Dalkowski's speed, all he had to do was stop walking 18 guys and he'd be successful. Trying to mess with multiple pitches and try to hit the corners was beyond his capacity. Dalkowski had his best year ever in the minors under Weaver, walking "only" 114 batters in 160 IP for AAA Elmira, and posting an ERA of 3.04. The previous year he had walked 196 in 103 innings and posted an ERA of 8.39.
Once Weaver had moved on to a new team, some coach tried to get Dalkowski to learn a curve and pitch to spots—and it all went to hell again. By 1964, Dalkowski's ERA for three minor league teams was back up to 6.27, and he was moving backward down the chain minor-league chain in one year from AAA to AA to A.
I think this tells us something about Weaver. In the majors as well as the minors, he was good at analyzing what a player could do, what they couldn't do, and helping them to get the maximum out of their abilities.
The Weaver story is referenced in the wiki article, but it's even better as told in Weaver's autobiography. This book has one of my all-time favorite titles: It's What you Learn After You Know It All that Counts.