ashburn or Dykstra

Ashburn or Dykstra for Phillies franchise team

Ashburn. He has never let me down when I've used him. My preference of cards is the 1958 one.

Depends on what park you're using. For my money, Dykstra is a better choice if your park is friendly to LH power.

I am inclined to agree with the Jumbo Jet (thetallguy747), I shy away from plus arms unless they are stone OPS guys but I would be inclined to take Dykstra, Ashburn just doesn't have enough pop for a guy who is not a big base-stealer, my opinion.

Ever since Ronnie Darling's latest book, I just can't stomach Dykstra anymore.

That said, yah, depends on park. Agree with prior remarks.

Chompsky - I feel that way about the Canseco that doesn't suffer from hangnails (the $8m one ) but I still always look

I actually played in a card and dice tournament that Dykstra's brother was in. He was a real dick, and from what I understand Lenny is even worse.

dykstra has always underperformed for me whereas ashburn has always done well... i've tried dykstra in many settings and he never comes through... i'm done with him...

I say neither.

Can you not go back in time? I'd look at Delahanty or Billy Hamilton as options.
If no oldies, then take a glance at Aaron Rowland or Shane Victorino.

Delahanty is probably my pick if available to you.