In my starting rotation I have Jim Bagby Sr from 1920 as my 5th starter.
I also have Jim Bagby Jr. on my staff from 1946 as a reserve.
After 9 games Jim Bagby Sr has no innings pitched but Jim Bagby Jr has 5 innings pitched.
Turns out it was Jim Bagby Jr who started that 5th game. I doubled and triple checked my rotation and the elder Jim Bagby is listed as my starter and he has not been injured. You cannot be injured not playing!
I lost that game so the glitch might have cost me a game and i have in the past missed the playoffs by one game.
The integrity of the game is effected here. Do I need to replace Jim Bagby 1946 ? 2 completely different people with different cards why does this happen and will it again?