Prevailing wisdom from the experts

I toy with pitcher's parks (Petco 1 1 1 1) in theme leagues that are predominately HR parks and HR hitting teams. I'll do this sometimes with themes where my team composition has quality hitters who are not super strong HR hitters, though, I have some HR hitters.

For my SPs in this kind of park, my thinking is that I will get better overall results from SPs like Denny McLain and Johan Santana over Dean Chance and Hal Newhouser (for example). The additional HRs McLain and Santana will give up (especially on the road) is more than offset by the lower OBP and pitching ~50% of their games at home. Most of the HRs are coming off the hitters' cards in any event and the lower OBP is at least providing few base runners around those HRs.

In general, I find a pitcher's park and 'fewer' HRs is not a winning proposition as most of the better records are the teams with more HRs than less. But, I have had some success.

By the way, this theme is 1946 forward, $ 140 million, two franchises.

I am not expecting that someone has studied this, but, what are impressions from the community about McLain and Santana vs Chance and Prince Hal?

I like Santana in Petco I never had any luck with Denny. I try to stay away from pitchers from 1968 they always seem to under perform for me.

I'd take Santana & Denny in Petco. Should have great numbers at home. But if your league is loaded with hitter parks you might see them blow up.

I like Santana in Petco I never had any luck with Denny. I try to stay away from pitchers from 1968 they always seem to under perform for me.

I try to stay away from pitchers from the year 1787

Had a foursome warming up in the bullpen that year WASHINGTON,ADAMS.JEFFERSON and MADISON . Unmatched then or now.

https://www.baseball-reference.com/play ... ge01.shtml

Here's an example of McLain & Santana in Petco: https://365.strat-o-matic.com/team/1600690

I think that's my highest projected wins (109) for ATG9.

FWIW, that league was pretty loaded with hitter's parks (average ballpark numbers were: 8.3 8.6 11.3 11.8): https://365.strat-o-matic.com/league/450896