- Posts: 3149
- Joined: Fri Aug 24, 2012 9:14 am
Rant wrote:I had Axis and Allies, but I always liked the less involved (Risk) when rubber hit road. I remember trying to decipher some of the rules myself, and getting very lost. My parents rarely played, sister had no interest, and my friend-group didn't skew toward board games, so that didn't help.
Less involved is the problem with Risk, it all comes down to dice rolls. A&A, has much more strategy, and different types of strategy than Risk. Adding a monetary element adds all kinds of levels to how you replace and replenish units and where and when to attack. Sometimes, attacks are made for monetary gain or opponent's loss, as much as for gaining territory.
Bringing this back to Strat, it's also why I prefer the Football board game to the Baseball board game. The play calling aspect and positioning of defensive players, adds a level of strategy not unlike chess and helps lessen the impact of the randomness of the dice. Baseball, on the other hand, seems to come down to dice no mater what you do. It's probably why the online game works great for baseball and is crappy as hell for football.