ANDY'S ALTERNATE HISTORY 13.0

ANDYS ALT13.0 Season #5 DRAFT
ROUND 1
1. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Hittmens) - Hal Trosky 1b
2. CHICAGO CUBS (caimrisek) - Terry Moore CF
3. ST. LOUIS BROWNS (andy) - (from BKN) - Cecil Travis 3b
4. CINCINNATI REDS (watsonjamey) - Frankie Crosetti SS
5. PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) - Clyde Shoun RP
6. ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - Phil Cavaretta 1b
7. BOSTON RED SOX (bontomn) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (Main Line Expos) -
9. (PHA, NYG, BKN(fromSLB)
10.
11.

ROUND 2
1. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Hittmens) -
2. CHICAGO CUBS (caimrisek) -
3. BROOKLYN DODGERS (Hamilton17) -
4. CINCINNATI REDS (watsonjamey) -
5. PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) -
6. ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - PASS
7. BOSTON RED SOX (bontomn) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (Main Line Expos) -
9. (PHA, PIT, NYG, BKN(fromSLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 3
1. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Hittmens) -
2. CHICAGO CUBS (caimrisek) -
3. BROOKLYN DODGERS (Hamilton17) -
4. CINCINNATI REDS (watsonjamey) -
5. PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) -
6. ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - PASS
7. BOSTON RED SOX (bontomn) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (Main Line Expos) -
9. (PHA, PIT, NYG, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 4
1. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Hittmens) -
2. CHICAGO CUBS (caimrisek) -
3. BROOKLYN DODGERS (Hamilton17) -
4. CINCINNATI REDS (watsonjamey) -
5. PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) -
6. ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - PASS
7. BOSTON RED SOX (bontomn) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (Main Line Expos) -
9. (PHA, PIT, NYG, BKN(fromSLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 5
1. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Hittmens) -
2. CHICAGO CUBS (caimrisek) -
3. BROOKLYN DODGERS (Hamilton17) -
4. CINCINNATI REDS (watsonjamey) -
5. PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) -
6. ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - PASS
7. BOSTON RED SOX (bontomn) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (Main Line Expos) -
9. (PHA, PIT, NYG, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 6
1. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Hittmens) -
2. CHICAGO CUBS (caimrisek) -
3. BROOKLYN DODGERS (Hamilton17) -
4. CINCINNATI REDS (watsonjamey) -
5. PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) -
6. ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - PASS
7. BOSTON RED SOX (bontomn) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (Main Line Expos) -
9. (PHA, PIT, NYG, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

FRANCHISE PICKS
BOSTON RED SOX - (bontomn) - 0 GA - Rudy York C/1b
BROOKLYN DODGERS - (Hamilton17) - 1 GA - Hugh Casey RP
CHICAGO CUBS - (caimrisek) - 0 GA - Stan Hack 3B, Terry Moore CF
CINCINNATI REDS - (watsonjamey) - 1 GA - Frank McCormack 1b
CLEVELAND INDIANS - (Hittmens) - 1 GA - Thornton Lee SP, Hal Trosky 1b
NEW YORK GIANTS - (emart) - 0 GA - Phil Weintraub OF
NEW YORK YANKEES - (Main Line Expos) - 1 GA - George Selkirk OF
PHILADELPHIA A's - (pacoboy) - 0 GA - Bob Johnson OF
PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) - 1 GA - Schoolboy Rowe P
PITTSBURGH PIRATES - (ironwill 1) - 0 GA - Arky Vaughan SS & Cy Blanton SP,
ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - 1 GA - Joe Medwick OF, Phil Cavaretta 1b
ST. LOUIS BROWNS (andy) - 1 GA - Harlond Clift 3b, Cecil Travis 3b


Allen, Johnny 5 8 SP
Auker, Elden 5 7 SP
Bell, Beau 5 7 OF
Benton, Al 5 10 RP
Bonura, Zeke 5 7 1B
Bowman, Joe 5 8 RP
Brennan, Don 5 6 RP
Brenzel, Bill 5 5 C
Brown, Mace 5 8 RP
Brubaker, Bill 5 7 IF
Camilli, Dolph 5 8 1B
Carleton, Tex 5 7 SP
Caster, George 5 8 RP
Castleman, Slick 5 6 SP
Chiozza, Lou 5 6 IF
Dahlgren, Babe 5 8 1b
Danning, Harry 5 7 C
Davis, Curt 5 8 SP
Dean, Paul 5 7 SP
Delancey, Bill 5 7 C
Demaree, Frank 5 8 OF
Dietrich, Bill 5 9 SP
Eisenstat, Harry 5 7 RP
Fletcher, Elbie 5 9 1B
Fox, Pete 5 8 OF
Frey, Lonny 5 9 2B
Gabler, Frank 5 6 SP
Galan, Augie 5 9 OF
Galatzer, Milt 5 6 OF/1B
Galehouse, Denny 5 9 SP
Gamble, Lee 5 7 OF
Goodman, Ival 5 8 OF
Grabowski, Reggie 5 5 SP/RP
Gumbert, Harry 5 9 SP
Gyselman, Dick 5 5 IF
Hamlin, Luke 5 8 SP
Hayes, Frankie 5 8 C
Heusser, Ed 5 9 RP
Holland, Dutch 5 5 OF
Hutchinson, Ira 5 8 RP
Jordan, Jimmy 5 6 IF
Kennedy, Vern 5 8 RP
Knickerbocker, Bill 5 7 SS
Knott, Jack 5 8 RP
Lavagetto, Cookie 5 8 3B/IF
Lee, Bill C. 5 8 SP
Leiber, Hank 5 7 OF
Leonard, Dutch 5 10 SP
Lewis, Buddy 5 9 3B
McGee, Bill 5 7 RP
Mills, Buster 5 8 OF
Moses, Wally 5 9 OF
Mueller, Ray 5 9 C
Mulcahy, Hugh 5 8 SP
Murphy, Johnny 5 8 RP
Myers, Billy 5 7 SS
O'Dea, Ken 5 8 C
Ostermueller, Fritz 5 9 SP
Passeau, Claude 5 8 SP
Pearson, Monte 5 7 SP
Pytlak, Frankie 5 8 C
Radcliff, Rip 5 7 OF
Richards, Paul 5 8 C
Riggs, Lew 5 8 3B
Ryba, Mike 5 8 RP
Salveson, Jack 5 8 RP
Sewell, Rip 5 9 SP
Siebert, Dick 5 8 1B
Smith, Al J. 5 8 RP/SP
Stainback, Tuck 5 8 OF
Sullivan, Joe 5 7 RP
Swift, Bill 5 7 RP
Todd, Al 5 7 C
Whitehead, Burgess 5 8 IF
Young, Pep 5 8 2B

ANDYS ALT13.0 Season #5 DRAFT
ROUND 1
1. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Hittmens) - Hal Trosky 1b
2. CHICAGO CUBS (caimrisek) - Terry Moore CF
3. ST. LOUIS BROWNS (andy) - (from BKN) - Cecil Travis 3b
4. CINCINNATI REDS (watsonjamey) - Frankie Crosetti SS
5. PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) - Clyde Shoun RP
6. ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - Phil Cavaretta 1b
7. BOSTON RED SOX (bontomn) - Zeke Bonura 1b
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (Main Line Expos) -
9. (PHA, NYG, BKN(fromSLB)
10.
11.

ROUND 2
1. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Hittmens) -
2. CHICAGO CUBS (caimrisek) -
3. BROOKLYN DODGERS (Hamilton17) -
4. CINCINNATI REDS (watsonjamey) -
5. PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) -
6. ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - PASS
7. BOSTON RED SOX (bontomn) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (Main Line Expos) -
9. (PHA, PIT, NYG, BKN(fromSLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 3
1. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Hittmens) -
2. CHICAGO CUBS (caimrisek) -
3. BROOKLYN DODGERS (Hamilton17) -
4. CINCINNATI REDS (watsonjamey) -
5. PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) -
6. ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - PASS
7. BOSTON RED SOX (bontomn) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (Main Line Expos) -
9. (PHA, PIT, NYG, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 4
1. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Hittmens) -
2. CHICAGO CUBS (caimrisek) -
3. BROOKLYN DODGERS (Hamilton17) -
4. CINCINNATI REDS (watsonjamey) -
5. PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) -
6. ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - PASS
7. BOSTON RED SOX (bontomn) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (Main Line Expos) -
9. (PHA, PIT, NYG, BKN(fromSLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 5
1. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Hittmens) -
2. CHICAGO CUBS (caimrisek) -
3. BROOKLYN DODGERS (Hamilton17) -
4. CINCINNATI REDS (watsonjamey) -
5. PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) -
6. ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - PASS
7. BOSTON RED SOX (bontomn) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (Main Line Expos) -
9. (PHA, PIT, NYG, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 6
1. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Hittmens) -
2. CHICAGO CUBS (caimrisek) -
3. BROOKLYN DODGERS (Hamilton17) -
4. CINCINNATI REDS (watsonjamey) -
5. PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) -
6. ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - PASS
7. BOSTON RED SOX (bontomn) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (Main Line Expos) -
9. (PHA, PIT, NYG, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

FRANCHISE PICKS
BOSTON RED SOX - (bontomn) - 0 GA - Rudy York C/1b, Zeke Bonura 1b
BROOKLYN DODGERS - (Hamilton17) - 1 GA - Hugh Casey RP
CHICAGO CUBS - (caimrisek) - 0 GA - Stan Hack 3B, Terry Moore CF
CINCINNATI REDS - (watsonjamey) - 1 GA - Frank McCormack 1b
CLEVELAND INDIANS - (Hittmens) - 1 GA - Thornton Lee SP, Hal Trosky 1b
NEW YORK GIANTS - (emart) - 0 GA - Phil Weintraub OF
NEW YORK YANKEES - (Main Line Expos) - 1 GA - George Selkirk OF
PHILADELPHIA A's - (pacoboy) - 0 GA - Bob Johnson OF
PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) - 1 GA - Schoolboy Rowe P
PITTSBURGH PIRATES - (ironwill 1) - 0 GA - Arky Vaughan SS & Cy Blanton SP,
ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - 1 GA - Joe Medwick OF, Phil Cavaretta 1b
ST. LOUIS BROWNS (andy) - 1 GA - Harlond Clift 3b, Cecil Travis 3b


Allen, Johnny 5 8 SP
Auker, Elden 5 7 SP
Bell, Beau 5 7 OF
Benton, Al 5 10 RP
Bowman, Joe 5 8 RP
Brennan, Don 5 6 RP
Brenzel, Bill 5 5 C
Brown, Mace 5 8 RP
Brubaker, Bill 5 7 IF
Camilli, Dolph 5 8 1B
Carleton, Tex 5 7 SP
Caster, George 5 8 RP
Castleman, Slick 5 6 SP
Chiozza, Lou 5 6 IF
Dahlgren, Babe 5 8 1b
Danning, Harry 5 7 C
Davis, Curt 5 8 SP
Dean, Paul 5 7 SP
Delancey, Bill 5 7 C
Demaree, Frank 5 8 OF
Dietrich, Bill 5 9 SP
Eisenstat, Harry 5 7 RP
Fletcher, Elbie 5 9 1B
Fox, Pete 5 8 OF
Frey, Lonny 5 9 2B
Gabler, Frank 5 6 SP
Galan, Augie 5 9 OF
Galatzer, Milt 5 6 OF/1B
Galehouse, Denny 5 9 SP
Gamble, Lee 5 7 OF
Goodman, Ival 5 8 OF
Grabowski, Reggie 5 5 SP/RP
Gumbert, Harry 5 9 SP
Gyselman, Dick 5 5 IF
Hamlin, Luke 5 8 SP
Hayes, Frankie 5 8 C
Heusser, Ed 5 9 RP
Holland, Dutch 5 5 OF
Hutchinson, Ira 5 8 RP
Jordan, Jimmy 5 6 IF
Kennedy, Vern 5 8 RP
Knickerbocker, Bill 5 7 SS
Knott, Jack 5 8 RP
Lavagetto, Cookie 5 8 3B/IF
Lee, Bill C. 5 8 SP
Leiber, Hank 5 7 OF
Leonard, Dutch 5 10 SP
Lewis, Buddy 5 9 3B
McGee, Bill 5 7 RP
Mills, Buster 5 8 OF
Moses, Wally 5 9 OF
Mueller, Ray 5 9 C
Mulcahy, Hugh 5 8 SP
Murphy, Johnny 5 8 RP
Myers, Billy 5 7 SS
O'Dea, Ken 5 8 C
Ostermueller, Fritz 5 9 SP
Passeau, Claude 5 8 SP
Pearson, Monte 5 7 SP
Pytlak, Frankie 5 8 C
Radcliff, Rip 5 7 OF
Richards, Paul 5 8 C
Riggs, Lew 5 8 3B
Ryba, Mike 5 8 RP
Salveson, Jack 5 8 RP
Sewell, Rip 5 9 SP
Siebert, Dick 5 8 1B
Smith, Al J. 5 8 RP/SP
Stainback, Tuck 5 8 OF
Sullivan, Joe 5 7 RP
Swift, Bill 5 7 RP
Todd, Al 5 7 C
Whitehead, Burgess 5 8 IF
Young, Pep 5 8 2B

Eisenstat, Harry 5 7 RP for the Yankees

Eisenstat, Harry 5 7 RP for the Yankees

Daniel, I've got Eisenstat listed as an RP, but he's not anymore, only SP. I'll leave this up for a little while to see if you want to make a change.

Bill Swift is an SP/RP, not an RP

Bill Swift is an SP/RP, not an RP

I have used swift more times than I should so yes I was well aware of that lol

ANDYS ALT13.0 Season #5 DRAFT
ROUND 1
1. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Hittmens) - Hal Trosky 1b
2. CHICAGO CUBS (caimrisek) - Terry Moore CF
3. ST. LOUIS BROWNS (andy) - (from BKN) - Cecil Travis 3b
4. CINCINNATI REDS (watsonjamey) - Frankie Crosetti SS
5. PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) - Clyde Shoun RP
6. ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - Phil Cavaretta 1b
7. BOSTON RED SOX (bontomn) - Zeke Bonura 1b
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (Main Line Expos) - Joe Sullivan RP
9. (PHA, NYG, BKN(fromSLB)
10.
11.

ROUND 2
1. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Hittmens) -
2. CHICAGO CUBS (caimrisek) -
3. BROOKLYN DODGERS (Hamilton17) -
4. CINCINNATI REDS (watsonjamey) -
5. PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) -
6. ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - PASS
7. BOSTON RED SOX (bontomn) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (Main Line Expos) -
9. (PHA, PIT, NYG, BKN(fromSLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 3
1. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Hittmens) -
2. CHICAGO CUBS (caimrisek) -
3. BROOKLYN DODGERS (Hamilton17) -
4. CINCINNATI REDS (watsonjamey) -
5. PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) -
6. ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - PASS
7. BOSTON RED SOX (bontomn) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (Main Line Expos) -
9. (PHA, PIT, NYG, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 4
1. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Hittmens) -
2. CHICAGO CUBS (caimrisek) -
3. BROOKLYN DODGERS (Hamilton17) -
4. CINCINNATI REDS (watsonjamey) -
5. PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) -
6. ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - PASS
7. BOSTON RED SOX (bontomn) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (Main Line Expos) -
9. (PHA, PIT, NYG, BKN(fromSLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 5
1. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Hittmens) -
2. CHICAGO CUBS (caimrisek) -
3. BROOKLYN DODGERS (Hamilton17) -
4. CINCINNATI REDS (watsonjamey) -
5. PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) -
6. ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - PASS
7. BOSTON RED SOX (bontomn) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (Main Line Expos) -
9. (PHA, PIT, NYG, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

ROUND 6
1. CLEVELAND INDIANS (Hittmens) -
2. CHICAGO CUBS (caimrisek) -
3. BROOKLYN DODGERS (Hamilton17) -
4. CINCINNATI REDS (watsonjamey) -
5. PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) -
6. ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - PASS
7. BOSTON RED SOX (bontomn) -
8. NEW YORK YANKEES (Main Line Expos) -
9. (PHA, PIT, NYG, SLB)
10.
11.
12.

FRANCHISE PICKS
BOSTON RED SOX - (bontomn) - 0 GA - Rudy York C/1b, Zeke Bonura 1b
BROOKLYN DODGERS - (Hamilton17) - 1 GA - Hugh Casey RP
CHICAGO CUBS - (caimrisek) - 0 GA - Stan Hack 3B, Terry Moore CF
CINCINNATI REDS - (watsonjamey) - 1 GA - Frank McCormack 1b
CLEVELAND INDIANS - (Hittmens) - 1 GA - Thornton Lee SP, Hal Trosky 1b
NEW YORK GIANTS - (emart) - 0 GA - Phil Weintraub OF
NEW YORK YANKEES - (Main Line Expos) - 1 GA - George Selkirk OF, Joe Sullivan RP
PHILADELPHIA A's - (pacoboy) - 0 GA - Bob Johnson OF
PHILADELPHIA PHILLIES (barterer2002) - 1 GA - Schoolboy Rowe P
PITTSBURGH PIRATES - (ironwill 1) - 0 GA - Arky Vaughan SS & Cy Blanton SP,
ST. LOUIS CARDINALS (drfreeze) - 1 GA - Joe Medwick OF, Phil Cavaretta 1b
ST. LOUIS BROWNS (andy) - 1 GA - Harlond Clift 3b, Cecil Travis 3b


Allen, Johnny 5 8 SP
Auker, Elden 5 7 SP
Bell, Beau 5 7 OF
Benton, Al 5 10 RP
Bowman, Joe 5 8 RP
Brennan, Don 5 6 RP
Brenzel, Bill 5 5 C
Brown, Mace 5 8 RP
Brubaker, Bill 5 7 IF
Camilli, Dolph 5 8 1B
Carleton, Tex 5 7 SP
Caster, George 5 8 RP
Castleman, Slick 5 6 SP
Chiozza, Lou 5 6 IF
Dahlgren, Babe 5 8 1b
Danning, Harry 5 7 C
Davis, Curt 5 8 SP
Dean, Paul 5 7 SP
Delancey, Bill 5 7 C
Demaree, Frank 5 8 OF
Dietrich, Bill 5 9 SP
Eisenstat, Harry 5 7 SP/RP
Fletcher, Elbie 5 9 1B
Fox, Pete 5 8 OF
Frey, Lonny 5 9 2B
Gabler, Frank 5 6 SP
Galan, Augie 5 9 OF
Galatzer, Milt 5 6 OF/1B
Galehouse, Denny 5 9 SP
Gamble, Lee 5 7 OF
Goodman, Ival 5 8 OF
Grabowski, Reggie 5 5 SP/RP
Gumbert, Harry 5 9 SP
Gyselman, Dick 5 5 IF
Hamlin, Luke 5 8 SP
Hayes, Frankie 5 8 C
Heusser, Ed 5 9 RP
Holland, Dutch 5 5 OF
Hutchinson, Ira 5 8 RP
Jordan, Jimmy 5 6 IF
Kennedy, Vern 5 8 RP
Knickerbocker, Bill 5 7 SS
Knott, Jack 5 8 RP
Lavagetto, Cookie 5 8 3B/IF
Lee, Bill C. 5 8 SP
Leiber, Hank 5 7 OF
Leonard, Dutch 5 10 SP
Lewis, Buddy 5 9 3B
McGee, Bill 5 7 RP
Mills, Buster 5 8 OF
Moses, Wally 5 9 OF
Mueller, Ray 5 9 C
Mulcahy, Hugh 5 8 SP
Murphy, Johnny 5 8 RP
Myers, Billy 5 7 SS
O'Dea, Ken 5 8 C
Ostermueller, Fritz 5 9 SP
Passeau, Claude 5 8 SP
Pearson, Monte 5 7 SP
Pytlak, Frankie 5 8 C
Radcliff, Rip 5 7 OF
Richards, Paul 5 8 C
Riggs, Lew 5 8 3B
Ryba, Mike 5 8 RP
Salveson, Jack 5 8 RP
Sewell, Rip 5 9 SP
Siebert, Dick 5 8 1B
Smith, Al J. 5 8 RP/SP
Stainback, Tuck 5 8 OF
Swift, Bill 5 7 SP/RP
Todd, Al 5 7 C
Whitehead, Burgess 5 8 IF
Young, Pep 5 8 2B

So I guess my question here is at what point does the responsibility fall on the owner to look at the card? I know the spreadsheet is a guide but it changes and we ultimately bear the responsibility to assess the accuracy for each player and position.

I kind of agree with Brian here. I have a whole roster built already with my entire eligible team. I look at every player card before I make a pick. We (as owners) ought to be checking cards anyway to verify salaries before we draft, it isn't like we aren't up against that 98M and needing to know if we are cutting someone to fit our draft picks or what we're doing. How long are we planning to wait on Main Line Expos to confirm his pick or not before we move on?

He's working on it now.

And while I agree with the fact we are all responsible for our rosters, I'd like for my mistake on the spreadsheet not to have a negative effect.