5DKL prospect draft (complete and recorded)

unctarheel wrote:
Please sign-in to confirm you status as a founding member of the league. You should also feel free to post suggested rule changes or typos that you discovered while reading over the league rule list.

(1) unctarheel - confirmed
(2) lakeviewdave - confirmed
(3) Jerlins - confirmed
(4) Muck
(5)Terry101- Confirm
(6) Chilliards - confirm
(7) mlbphan
(8) jmlopp - Confirmed
(9) TefJ
(10) klx22
(11) Roscodog - IN
(12) baseball cfo - confirmed

unctarheel wrote:
Please sign-in to confirm you status as a founding member of the league. You should also feel free to post suggested rule changes or typos that you discovered while reading over the league rule list.

(1) unctarheel - confirmed
(2) lakeviewdave - confirmed
(3) Jerlins - confirmed
(4) Muck
(5)Terry101- Confirm
(6) Chilliards - confirm
(7) mlbphan - confirm
(8) jmlopp - Confirmed
(9) TefJ
(10) klx22
(11) Roscodog - IN
(12) baseball cfo - confirmed

(1) unctarheel - confirmed
(2) lakeviewdave - confirmed
(3) Jerlins - confirmed
(4) Muck
(5)Terry101- Confirm
(6) Chilliards - confirm
(7) mlbphan - confirm
(8) jmlopp - Confirmed
(9) TefJ - Confirmed
(10) klx22
(11) Roscodog - IN
(12) baseball cfo - confirmed

Mon Apr 10, 2023 11:53 am

(1) unctarheel - confirmed
(2) lakeviewdave - confirmed
(3) Jerlins - confirmed
(4) Muck - confirmed
(5)Terry101- Confirm
(6) Chilliards - confirm
(7) mlbphan - confirm
(8) jmlopp - Confirmed
(9) TefJ - Confirmed
(10) klx22
(11) Roscodog - IN
(12) baseball cfo - confirmed

Mon Apr 10, 2023 11:53 am

(1) unctarheel - confirmed
(2) lakeviewdave - confirmed
(3) Jerlins - confirmed
(4) Muck - confirmed
(5)Terry101- Confirm
(6) Chilliards - confirm
(7) mlbphan - confirm
(8) jmlopp - Confirmed
(9) TefJ - Confirmed
(10) klx22 _ IN
(11) Roscodog - IN
(12) baseball cfo - confirmed

So i guess we need a randomizer & off we go? I know there was some proposal about discussing some of the rules once we fill. My opinion is there does not need to be any kind of percentage for pitchers or hitters and I believe all picks (including prospect picks) should be tradeable. Also, i think we need 41 rounds to get a get a stadium and a 40 man roster vs 29.

My biggest concern is will a yearly players available list be provided (other than this year of course)?

While we are waiting for the last few managers to check-in, I'd like to survey everyone with regards to the time limits we would like to use during the initial draft. Obviously no time-limit for Round 1, but beyond that what is the consensus. I am used to two-hour slots, 10 a.m. to 10 p.m. Eastern Time, seven-days a week for the subsequent rounds, but I have less experience than many of you playing keeper leagues so feel free to advocate for an alternate format.

While we are waiting for the last few managers to check-in, I'd like to survey everyone with regards to the time limits we would like to use during the initial draft. Obviously no time-limit for Round 1, but beyond that what is the consensus. I am used to two-hour slots, 10 a.m. to 10 p.m. Eastern Time, seven-days a week for the subsequent rounds, but I have less experience than many of you playing keeper leagues so feel free to advocate for an alternative format.

Everyone has now checked in. I think it would be best to get rules finalized before start drafting so everyone is on the same page.

As far as time slots, 2hr slots 10-10 x7d is fine with me after 1st round.

I agree with klx22 about the percentages and tradability of picks. As for the draft, I believe the idea was to fill our rosters over time, but I'd be open to either way.

Are we using Unleashed or Regular? I'd vote Regular since the main FA draft is prior to the cards being revealed. If we went with Unleashed we'd have weird guessing games trying to find the cards like Hensley in this set.

Otherwise, I think the rules are great, and I'm looking forward to getting started!