- Posts: 535
- Joined: Wed Dec 25, 2013 7:41 pm
When Hal Richman created the mystery game, he noticed how player performance changed from year to year which made baseball and infinitely interesting game. Here is more data supporting how the same players with the same teams can yield very very different results. Here’s a look at how the teams did in season 1 and how the new owners are doing thus far in season 2.
The two teams with over 100 losses in season 1 are in first place with about 1/4 of the season complete.
East—Season 2--
(Records referenced are as of Sunday morning—this posting was delayed until Monday)
Houston Astros (YCBil)—24-15 (8 games ahead of season 1 record with Burley Norseman)
Atlanta Braves ((Burley Norseman)—21-18 (5 games behind season 1 record with YCBIll)
Montreal Expos (PBDaileyfl)—21-18 (6 games ahead of season 1 record with Fench33)
New York Yankees (KaiserWill4)—19-20 (7 games behind season 1 record with MFL536)
Central
Cincinnati Reds (Generationm1)—23-16 (9 games ahead of season 1 record with Nol15736
San Francisco Giants (Bigdinkent) 20-19 (5 games ahead of season 1 record with JJB92)
Oakland Athletics (Nol15736) 20-22 (9 games behind season 1 record with Generationm1)
Texas Rangers (JJB92) 17-22 (3 games ahead of season 1 record with Bigdinkent)
West
Minnesota Twins (NewGuy1912)—22-17 (10 games ahead of season 1 record with Drabb9529)
Cleveland Indians/Guardians (Fench33) 20-19 (1 game behind season 1 record with PBDaileyfl)
Seattle Mariners (Drabb9529) 18-21 (8 games behind season 1 record with NewGuy1912)
St. Louis Cardinals (MFL536) 10-29 (5 games behind season 1 record with Manillacone—Note, Manillacone was unable to participate in season 2—his slot was taken by KaiserWill4)
Interesting notes on each team
Houston—Greg Swindell is 6-1—ERA 1.89/WHIP 1.01. Billy Wagner 17 saves, 1 blown save—.87 ERA, .97 WHIP. Brad Ausmus—.282/.383/.466—5 home runs/13 RBI.
Atlanta Braves—Big three of Greg Maddux, John Smoltz and Tom Glavine are 16-10 with ERAs of 3.61, 2.88, 3.25. The big three are consistent with season 1 results----Greg 19-19, John 19-14 and Tom 14-22. Eddie Perez has taken over as starting catcher—.330/.421/.495——2 home runs, 15 RBI. Last year? .158/.200/.184 in only 40 plate appearances.
Montreal Expos: Pedro Martinez is off to a great start—7-2, ERA of 1.21/WHIP .84. The Expos made a great trade acquiring Will Clark from Rangers—Will is at .327/.432/.524 5 home runs/21 RBI. Last year, Pedro was 14-15 3.72/1.26 WHIP.
New York Yankees: Bernie Williams is off to a good start but is now battling injuries—he’s out for the next 8 games after missing 3 games earlier. Bernie is at .384/.438/.652 with 10 home runs/28 RBI. Don Mattingly is struggling—he’s at .241/.274.324. Andy Pettite is 1-5 with an ERA of 6.03/1.61 WHIP. Don's results last year were .269/.359/.413 with 18 home runs while Andy was 18-15 3.92/1.44.
Cincinatti Reds: Pete Schourek (4-0) and Jack Armstrong (4-0) have not lost this season. Hal Morris had an epically bad year in season 1 but is off to a nice start in season 2——.321/.351.415. His season 1 results? .221/.250/.274 in 271 plate appearances
San Francisco Giants: John Burkett is 5-3—ERA of 2.30/WHIP of 1.07. Stan Javier is at .273/.313/.417. Last season, John got released after going 4-6 4.46/1.51. Stan was traded after contributing .222/.265/.315. On the other side, Salomon Torres went 16-8 3.58/1.23. This season? He’s been released 2-3, 7.12/1.55.
Oakland Athletics: Jimmy Haynes is off to an impressive start—he’s at 7-3 with a 3.64/1.31. Dennis Eckersley has not allowed a run this season in 16 innings—he’s only allowed 3 hits. On the other side, Matt Stairs is at .136/.333/.341 in 56 plate appearances. He has hit 3 home runs/driven in 9 runs. Last season, Matt contributed .266/.354/.494 blasting 30 home runs.
Texas Rangers: Juan Gonzalez was a monster last year—48 home runs, 138 runs knocked in—.298/.362/.814. This season is a very different story—.179/.222/.343 with 3 home runs in 70 plate appearances. Juan has already missed 19 games with injuries. Bobby Witt is off to a great start—he’s 5-1 2.63/1.08 WHIP. Last season? Bobby was 1-7 with a 5.79/1.59 and was released.
Minnesota Twins: Pat Rapp is 2-1 in 35 innings—ERA 2.06/1.17 WHIP. Pedro Munoz .319/.361/.550—4 home runs in 97 plate appearances. Last year—Pat was 7-10 with 4.87/1.48. Pedro had 102 plate appearances before being released—Pedro was at .232/.284/.337 with 2 home runs.
Cleveland Indians: Albie Lopez led the team in wins—he was 14-8 for the season. His ERA was 3.96/1.34 WHIP. This year? 0-7—ERA of 10.18 and a WHIP of 2.41.
Charles Nagy—was 6-8—only pitched 99 innings for the season. 5.71 ERA/1.40 WHIP. This year? Charles has been pitching like an ace—7-1 with ERA of 2.47/1.33.
Jim Thome—.296/.411//.581 with 39 home runs and 96 RBI. Jim’s power has stayed—14 home runs but a slash line of .219/.321/.519.
Seattle Mariners—Last season league champion Seattle was led by Ken Griffey Jr. who blasted 62 home runs and a slash line of .297/.379/.628 and Alex Rodriguez who hit 39 home runs .300/.379/.513 with 39 home runs. Tino Martinez and Jay Buhner played supporting roles—neither had outstanding years—Tino .249/.348/.453 with 17 home runs. Jay hit 38 home runs but his slash line was .238/.335/.485.
Things have changed this year—Jr. and Alex haven’t found last years magic. Jr is at .253/.332/.500 while Alex is at .205/.301/.477. Jay has picked up the slack—he’s at .281/.360/.641 with 18 home runs. Tino is at .250/.312/.579 with 12 home runs.
St. Louis Cardinals: Ozzie Smith—.218/.292/.272 in 589 ABs. Todd Zeile—35 doubles and 14 home runs—.260/.332/.392.
Todd is at .223/.257/.369 with only 2 home runs. Ozzie leads the team in stolen bases with 11 and is at .259/.345/.333.
The two teams with over 100 losses in season 1 are in first place with about 1/4 of the season complete.
East—Season 2--
(Records referenced are as of Sunday morning—this posting was delayed until Monday)
Houston Astros (YCBil)—24-15 (8 games ahead of season 1 record with Burley Norseman)
Atlanta Braves ((Burley Norseman)—21-18 (5 games behind season 1 record with YCBIll)
Montreal Expos (PBDaileyfl)—21-18 (6 games ahead of season 1 record with Fench33)
New York Yankees (KaiserWill4)—19-20 (7 games behind season 1 record with MFL536)
Central
Cincinnati Reds (Generationm1)—23-16 (9 games ahead of season 1 record with Nol15736
San Francisco Giants (Bigdinkent) 20-19 (5 games ahead of season 1 record with JJB92)
Oakland Athletics (Nol15736) 20-22 (9 games behind season 1 record with Generationm1)
Texas Rangers (JJB92) 17-22 (3 games ahead of season 1 record with Bigdinkent)
West
Minnesota Twins (NewGuy1912)—22-17 (10 games ahead of season 1 record with Drabb9529)
Cleveland Indians/Guardians (Fench33) 20-19 (1 game behind season 1 record with PBDaileyfl)
Seattle Mariners (Drabb9529) 18-21 (8 games behind season 1 record with NewGuy1912)
St. Louis Cardinals (MFL536) 10-29 (5 games behind season 1 record with Manillacone—Note, Manillacone was unable to participate in season 2—his slot was taken by KaiserWill4)
Interesting notes on each team
Houston—Greg Swindell is 6-1—ERA 1.89/WHIP 1.01. Billy Wagner 17 saves, 1 blown save—.87 ERA, .97 WHIP. Brad Ausmus—.282/.383/.466—5 home runs/13 RBI.
Atlanta Braves—Big three of Greg Maddux, John Smoltz and Tom Glavine are 16-10 with ERAs of 3.61, 2.88, 3.25. The big three are consistent with season 1 results----Greg 19-19, John 19-14 and Tom 14-22. Eddie Perez has taken over as starting catcher—.330/.421/.495——2 home runs, 15 RBI. Last year? .158/.200/.184 in only 40 plate appearances.
Montreal Expos: Pedro Martinez is off to a great start—7-2, ERA of 1.21/WHIP .84. The Expos made a great trade acquiring Will Clark from Rangers—Will is at .327/.432/.524 5 home runs/21 RBI. Last year, Pedro was 14-15 3.72/1.26 WHIP.
New York Yankees: Bernie Williams is off to a good start but is now battling injuries—he’s out for the next 8 games after missing 3 games earlier. Bernie is at .384/.438/.652 with 10 home runs/28 RBI. Don Mattingly is struggling—he’s at .241/.274.324. Andy Pettite is 1-5 with an ERA of 6.03/1.61 WHIP. Don's results last year were .269/.359/.413 with 18 home runs while Andy was 18-15 3.92/1.44.
Cincinatti Reds: Pete Schourek (4-0) and Jack Armstrong (4-0) have not lost this season. Hal Morris had an epically bad year in season 1 but is off to a nice start in season 2——.321/.351.415. His season 1 results? .221/.250/.274 in 271 plate appearances
San Francisco Giants: John Burkett is 5-3—ERA of 2.30/WHIP of 1.07. Stan Javier is at .273/.313/.417. Last season, John got released after going 4-6 4.46/1.51. Stan was traded after contributing .222/.265/.315. On the other side, Salomon Torres went 16-8 3.58/1.23. This season? He’s been released 2-3, 7.12/1.55.
Oakland Athletics: Jimmy Haynes is off to an impressive start—he’s at 7-3 with a 3.64/1.31. Dennis Eckersley has not allowed a run this season in 16 innings—he’s only allowed 3 hits. On the other side, Matt Stairs is at .136/.333/.341 in 56 plate appearances. He has hit 3 home runs/driven in 9 runs. Last season, Matt contributed .266/.354/.494 blasting 30 home runs.
Texas Rangers: Juan Gonzalez was a monster last year—48 home runs, 138 runs knocked in—.298/.362/.814. This season is a very different story—.179/.222/.343 with 3 home runs in 70 plate appearances. Juan has already missed 19 games with injuries. Bobby Witt is off to a great start—he’s 5-1 2.63/1.08 WHIP. Last season? Bobby was 1-7 with a 5.79/1.59 and was released.
Minnesota Twins: Pat Rapp is 2-1 in 35 innings—ERA 2.06/1.17 WHIP. Pedro Munoz .319/.361/.550—4 home runs in 97 plate appearances. Last year—Pat was 7-10 with 4.87/1.48. Pedro had 102 plate appearances before being released—Pedro was at .232/.284/.337 with 2 home runs.
Cleveland Indians: Albie Lopez led the team in wins—he was 14-8 for the season. His ERA was 3.96/1.34 WHIP. This year? 0-7—ERA of 10.18 and a WHIP of 2.41.
Charles Nagy—was 6-8—only pitched 99 innings for the season. 5.71 ERA/1.40 WHIP. This year? Charles has been pitching like an ace—7-1 with ERA of 2.47/1.33.
Jim Thome—.296/.411//.581 with 39 home runs and 96 RBI. Jim’s power has stayed—14 home runs but a slash line of .219/.321/.519.
Seattle Mariners—Last season league champion Seattle was led by Ken Griffey Jr. who blasted 62 home runs and a slash line of .297/.379/.628 and Alex Rodriguez who hit 39 home runs .300/.379/.513 with 39 home runs. Tino Martinez and Jay Buhner played supporting roles—neither had outstanding years—Tino .249/.348/.453 with 17 home runs. Jay hit 38 home runs but his slash line was .238/.335/.485.
Things have changed this year—Jr. and Alex haven’t found last years magic. Jr is at .253/.332/.500 while Alex is at .205/.301/.477. Jay has picked up the slack—he’s at .281/.360/.641 with 18 home runs. Tino is at .250/.312/.579 with 12 home runs.
St. Louis Cardinals: Ozzie Smith—.218/.292/.272 in 589 ABs. Todd Zeile—35 doubles and 14 home runs—.260/.332/.392.
Todd is at .223/.257/.369 with only 2 home runs. Ozzie leads the team in stolen bases with 11 and is at .259/.345/.333.