5dkl keeper league - preseason prospect draft Jan. 15, 2025

In the interest of starting the draft on time, I'll vote yes. I would like to submit my proposal, though it can be done when we have another rule to vote on, for another draft.

Proposed rule adoption
With respected to the preseason prospect draft, "the tie-breaker goes to the team with best head-to-head record across the previous two seasons (Season 1 and Season2), else it is determined by random draw."

Please vote "YES" to adopt, or vote "NO" to reject this rule adoption.

1. unctarheel YES
2. traderider YES
3. Jerlins YES
4. klx22 NO
5. Muck YES
6. mlbphan NO …… because I agree with klx22 …… I knew there was a reason I was questioning in my head this proposal
7. TefJ YES

Please vote "YES" to adopt, or vote "NO" to reject this rule adoption.

1. unctarheel YES
2. traderider YES
3. Jerlins YES
4. klx22 NO
5. Muck YES
6. mlbphan NO …… because I agree with klx22 …… I knew there was a reason I was questioning in my head this proposal
7. TefJ YES
8. B_T@ylor7 YES

Proposed rule adoption
With respected to the preseason prospect draft, "the tie-breaker goes to the team with best head-to-head record across the previous two seasons (Season 1 and Season2), else it is determined by random draw."

Please vote "YES" to adopt, or vote "NO" to reject this rule adoption.

1. unctarheel - YES
2. traderider - YES
3. Jerlins - YES
4. klx22 - NO
5. Muck - YES
6. mlbphan - NO …… because I agree with klx22 …… I knew there was a reason I was questioning in my head this proposal
7. TefJ - YES
8. B_T@ylor7 - YES

Proposed rule adoption
With respected to the preseason prospect draft, "the tie-breaker goes to the team with best head-to-head record across the previous two seasons (Season 1 and Season2), else it is determined by random draw."

Please vote "YES" to adopt, or vote "NO" to reject this rule adoption.

1. unctarheel - YES
2. traderider - YES
3. Jerlins - YES
4. klx22 - NO
5. Muck - YES
6. mlbphan - NO …… because I agree with klx22 …… I knew there was a reason I was questioning in my head this proposal
7. TefJ - YES
8. B_T@ylor7 - YES

current count: 6 YES 2 NO
draft order for the preseason prospect draft will be posted as soon as the tie-breaker format has been determined

Proposed rule adoption
With respected to the preseason prospect draft, "the tie-breaker goes to the team with best head-to-head record across the previous two seasons (Season 1 and Season2), else it is determined by random draw."

Please vote "YES" to adopt, or vote "NO" to reject this rule adoption.

1. unctarheel - YES
2. traderider - YES
3. Jerlins - YES
4. klx22 - NO
5. Muck - YES
6. mlbphan - NO …… because I agree with klx22 …… I knew there was a reason I was questioning in my head this proposal
7. TefJ - YES
8. B_T@ylor7 - YES
9. baseball cfo - YES

current count: 6 YES 2 NO
draft order for the preseason prospect draft will be posted as soon as the tie-breaker format has been determined

Rule adoption (by a vote of 7 to 2)
With respect to the preseason prospect draft, "the tie-breaker goes to the team with best head-to-head record across the previous two seasons (Season 1 and Season2), else it is determined by random draw."

Please vote "YES" to adopt, or vote "NO" to reject this rule adoption.

1. unctarheel - YES
2. traderider - YES
3. Jerlins - YES
4. klx22 - NO
5. Muck - YES
6. mlbphan - NO …… because I agree with klx22 …… I knew there was a reason I was questioning in my head this proposal
7. TefJ - YES
8. B_T@ylor7 - YES
9. baseball cfo - YES

Draft order for 2025 preseason prospect draft

1. Traderider 145 combined wins (wins tie-breaker with 20-16 record in head-to-head contests)
2. Muck 145 combined wins
3. Chilliards 147 combined wins
4. mlbphan 149 combined wins
5. baseballcfo 155 combined wins (wins tie-breaker with 19-14 record in head-to-head contests)
6. terry101 155 combined wins
7. klx22 157 combined wins
8. awesomepossum (formerly jmlopp) 164 combined wins (wins tie-breaker with 13-11 record in head-to-head contests)
9. TefJ 164 combined wins
10. B_T@ylor7 (formerly lakeviewdave) 177 combined wins
11. Jerlins 186 combined wins
12. unctarheel 200 combined wins

The draft order for this draft is serpentine, so the order of picks shown above applies to Round 1 and Round 3. The order of picks will thus be reversed in Rounds 2 and 4.

TefJ was the only manager impacted by the 20-man cap on the prospect rosters at this time. He has elected to cut Ryan Fernandez from his 40-man roster and promote Jackson Merrill to that spot, cutting his prospect total to 16. This move will permit him to pick in all four rounds of this prospect draft.

Our 2025 preseason prospect draft will officially begin at 0000 EST on January 15. This means that eligible draftees are those players (a) without prior MLB experience (b) who were under contract to a franchise in any professional league, as of January 14, 2025, and (c) who do not appear on a current 5dkl team roster.

...so I should send an urgent appeal to Sasaki to sign before next Wednesday??