by Palanion » Mon Apr 14, 2008 12:03 pm
Fielding in Fenway for the Red Sox has always been a mixed bag. But winning the Gold Glove is not common in Boston.
And they had Dwight Evans in RF, who is still one of the best defensive RF I have ever seen - 8 gold gloves.
In the '80s they went through a plethora of CF looking for that one guy who could hit and field. Rick Miller, Reid Nichols, Garry Hancock, Tony Armas, Dave Henderson, Kevin Romine, etc. until they finally got Ellis Burks (1 gold glove). Of course, I think Crisp could have gotten one last year, and maybe Ellsbury will in the future.
In LF, they've always settled for the offense, though some have played better defensively than others: Teddy Ballgame, Yaz, Jim Ed, Greenie, Troy O'Leary, and Manny. Yaz (7 gold gloves) was easily the best of that bunch defensively.
First base was often where older or slower guys played, a la Yaz, Buckner, Baylor, Vaughn, Ortiz. Though Youkilis is a Gold Glover now, and with Lowell out, Sean Casey is not shabby there.
Catcher was always pretty good, though more about knowing how to call a game and manage pitchers than be a Gold Glover: Gedman, MacFarlane, Tony Pena (1 gold glove), Cerone, Mike Stanley, and Varitek (one gold glove).
Middle infield was weird. For a long time, they seemed to shuffle through guys trying to find the right blend. Marty Barrett, Jackie Gutierrez, Glenn Hoffman, Spike Owen, Luis Rivera, Jody Reed, and so on. Then they had some good ones for a while with John Valentin, Nomah!, Scott Fletcher, Scott Cooper, and Tim Naehring. In fact, I bet they're best infield defense of the 1980-2000 era was when they had Valentin at 2B, Nomar at SS, and Naehring at 3B.
Wade Boggs was the only Red Sox infielder in this period to win any gold gloves, except he wasn't a Red Sox by then. Statistically, if you go by the research done by www.baseball-reference.com, Boggs had his best defensive seasons in 1995 and 1996 in New York, but he got the GG in 1994 and 1995.
An aside: When Boggs first came up in 1982, they tried him at 1B because third was occupied by Carney Lansford. In the offseason, they let Lansford go via FA, and Boggs got the 3B job. Dave Stapleton was the full-time 1B, though Boggs played 44 games there in 1982.
Also, as for 1s at 3B in Strat, I recall Gary Gaetti and Robin Ventura being among the few to get them in the '80s and early '90s (with Pendleton and Schmidt, so a 2 was deemed great when I played tabletop. In fact I think guys like Kelly Gruber and Tim Wallach were never 1s in Strat, though they won gold gloves.
Lastly, Keith Hernandez and Jody Davis are 2s in 1986 Strat - but won the Gold Glove. For Hernandez, it was his 9th of 11 honors.