Would You Make This Trade?

[CATom]

BIG mistake - Manny has one of the BEST cards in the deck and even at a "3" Hudson is pretty solid --- he won't get the HR's Utley will BUT he'll outhim him for average AND OBP......BIG MISTAKE, you'll see :)

Tom.

[RICHARDMILTER]

LM Bombers wisely stated:[quote:702457cf3d]Why is Manny listed as an injury concern? He has over 600 PA. If that is a concern for injury then there aren't many players not to be concerned about.[/quote:702457cf3d]


LM is correct, Manny Ramirez is NOT the injury risk I thought he was. I do not know what I was thinking. He did miss 12 games for me, but he is over 600 plate appearances, so he can NOT miss more than 3 games at a time.

The Trade offer you received seems like a fairly even one. Hudson is still an injury risk, but the trade is a pretty fair offer. I do not think you will make a huge mistake either way. But if my 3 cents count;....I say make the deal. Why not? You will get a upgrade hitting from Manny, and a great glove in the center of the diamond from Hudson. Unless you are in a SERIOUS HR park, Chase Utley struggles to come close to his ,"Real life" power(and offensive) numbers.

LM thanks for correcting my mistake( misinformation) about Manny Ramirez.