by JONCHUCKERY » Thu Apr 22, 2010 7:54 pm
[quote:6bb0374a7f="The Senators"][quote:6bb0374a7f="jmc316"][quote:6bb0374a7f="The Senators"]The thing about Brett is that unless you play in a homer park and opt for Schmidt, the dropoff between Brett and the next 3rd baseman is huge....I think that's what makes him even more valuable.[/quote:6bb0374a7f]
Not sure I agree because you have some valuable players who can play 3rd...D Allen, Buford, Perez, Killebrew, Rose. So whether you need power or top of the order guys there are good choices...and if you hit the right card Torre, Bailey, and Evans can be monsters for the money.
To use an extreme...I had D Allen commit 48 errors at 3rd in the same season he hit 57HRs, had 140RS and 142RBI[/quote:6bb0374a7f]Aren't guys like Dick Allen and Killebrew and maybe even Perez going to post huge numbers only in homer parks? And if you're not, you have to settle for the 48 errors without all the home runs. Then again, I don't really know exactly since I rarely play in them. Buford's OK offensively, but he's a butcher too...Rose is not cheap either. All things considered, I'll take Brett.[/quote:6bb0374a7f]
I've had Allen hit 30+HRs, 100+RBI, 100+RS in the Astrodome...I've had Rose hit 15HRs with 100+ RS and RBI in Royals...you can get production from guys in different ways. 3B is not a position that gets many gbX chances to start so D is least important there over any INF position. If for 2.5mil less D Buford gives me 100+RS, a .385OBP, 10HRs, 70RBI, 20+SB I'll take that all day long